Based on 183 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.9 stars. Price $
Address:
206 Main St, Jay, ME 04239
Phone: (207) 897-5306
Menu
… View more
Reviews
Joseph
I’m originally from a city in New York called Amsterdam, where there is great pizza joints. Lots of Italian restaurants. I moved to Maine in 1993 and had difficulty finding a really good pizza. I found it in Jay. Yanni’s is the best pizza I’ve had in a long time. Great pizza!
… more
Mar S
Ordered two large pizzas and one SMALL calzone, $50!!!!!? What??? Pickup.
… more
Jeremy Puckett
First time in today. Brought two pizzas home and they were fantastic! Seems to be quality ingredients and the cooking was perfect. I’ll be back. Thank you!
… more
Chris
Got a decent size order today. The pizza was cooked perfectly and the toppings and dough were really fresh. the chicken fingers and the wings were awesome, best chicken fingers Ive had in a while. Their greek pizza was great, we added chicken to it. The chicken parm sub was loaded and I could only eat half. Prices we fair and reasonable, portions were large, and they even gave me a free 2 liter bottle of soda on the house. The kitchen and dining room were clean. Nice people too. Five stars.
… more
Basic Stuff
I’m from Connecticut and know real Italian food this is the real deal. Ignore the low ratings I missed this place for two years due to them. Wish I stopped in sooner. Google ratings don’t mean much up here just have to try it to know if it’s good!
… more
Chris Burnham
Honestly my worst experience with a business ever. I called, and asked about deals. I was told that their was a 2 large 1 topping pizzas for about $21. I said “cool, ill do that, with bacon on both please” It took over an hour for the pizza to even arrive, and once it did? lo and behold they only sent one pizza. I called them to find out what had happened, and was told that they only charged me for one pizza. Okay, whatever. Mistakes happen right? I was told that I would be charged the difference for the deal and they would send me the pizza as soon as possible. I said okay and hung up. the delivery driver left, who I still tipped by the way, and I then called back to double check that they wouldn’t charge me delivery again, since it was their mistake. I was told “no no of course not” Okay, all seems cool, right? wrong. because, once again, an hour passed, and no one has arrived. So I call to find out whats going on this time. Apparently I was told that they would correct the mistake, and then they just completely brushed it away. I was told that they weren’t gunna do it, and then they had the audacity to get mad at me for expecting the mistake to be corrected, despite them having told me twice it would be. If I could leave less then 1 star I would. This is by far the worst experience I’ve ever had with a business anywhere. I believe the boss and owners exact words were “I’m not going to effing do it”. absolutely horrid customer service, and I would not recommend ever going here, especially if its for delivery.
… more
Shauna Consaul
My family and I went on vacation to Maine and happened to come along this little place. Food is pretty good , the customer service NOT so good at all !!! Not sure if the old man working is the owner but let me just say WOW !!!! The attitude and eye rolling for asking for simple things like paper plates & ketchup was unreal especially considering you can not eat inside and we were from out of town on our way home so had to eat with our children I’m the car !! So stinking RUDE ! Should of been appreciative for the business Won’t ever be BACK !!
… more
Vanessa Volkening
Ordered 3 small steak subs, MOZZERELLA STICKS, and baklava. Nothing labeled. No receipt. And, after having the order repeated by two people during ordering, still did NOT get the MOZZARELLA STICKS. Still almost $40? Charlie ADMITS his menu is years outdated on pricing but doesn’t update it. And STILL, no MOZZERELLA STICKS!
… more
Shane Beaulieu
Best french fries I’ve had in a very long time. Fresh, a little crisp, and soft…didn’t use a drop of ketchup; they were that good. Had the steak bomb sub which was very good, too. It’ll be the fries that bring me back around.
… more
Justin Kendall
Best restaurant in Franklin county. Fast friendly service, great tasting food that you can’t get anywhere else. Reasonable prices for the amount of food you get. Excellent delivery service that’s fast.
… more
… View more