Based on 344 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
2528 NY-12B, Hamilton, NY 13346
Phone: (315) 824-1800
Hours
| Tuesday | 4–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 4–10 PM |
| Saturday | 4–10 PM |
| Sunday | 4–9 PM |
| Monday | 4–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: mealhi5.com
Reviews
brittney jorgensen
Ordered for the first time Paid 80$ for garbage! Wings were suppose to be garlic, I don’t know what they were but they were not! Wings were soggy left in an inch of oil. Not a single one was cooked properly not even a crunchy outside! Ordered two pizzas as well one wasn’t cooked all the way dough in the crust was raw and the other was burnt. I would never recommend to anyone, I’d rather buy frozen at least I know it will be done and it won’t cost me 80$.
… more
Debbie Jeff
For $56 we got a one topping pizza and 20 Tiny Soggy wings. The menu online was 10 years old so we were really surprised when we got there to pick up the pizza and wings and found out that the bill came to $56. I’m not sure what was going on with the skin on the tiny tiny and I mean “tiny wings” but it seem to be disintegrating into the sauce.
… more
Cheryl Wallace
got there at 4pm they didn’t open til 4:15 then no pizza for an hour while ovens heat up. salad bat was not set up yet. we ordered wings sold by 5s, never heard of that. we ordered 20 wings, 4 salad bars, 3 drinks cost 54 dollars. we were brought 3 salad bowls. they made us pay for another and I KNOW I told her FOUR! so now it’s a 60 dollar meal. 5 wings each and a salad. salad bar was very sparse, 3 containers of cucumbers. very basic ingrediants and containers barely had anything in them. NOT WORTH 60 DOLLARS!
… more
Steve Carey
I am a long long long time customer of the sherrill location. I recently went to Hamilton as sherrill was closed for memorial day. I asked for them to cook my pizza so the cheese was crispy , and to cook my potato wedges until crispy . The staff at the counter said “we arent allowed to cook anything crispy here” .. the cheese on the pizza was almost raw , and the potato wedges weren’t even cooked through let alone crispy. They should change thier name to something else , when you visit a chain (even one with only 2 locations ) you expect comparable food at all locations and the food here was just terrible I won’t be back..
… more
Russell Sheldon
Great place for pizza and tiny wings. It’s been 30 years since the last time I was here. The place hasn’t changed, it is still a great place to go to.
… more
Corin Oley
It was our first time going there and we will definitely be back. The Antipasto and Pizza were delicious
… more
David Syracuse
The interior is dim and clean, although dated. The pizza was greasy and doughy, and the wings were adequate. It’s certainly an experience. The menu is limited.
… more
Sarah Williams
We usually get food to go but they do have dine in. There are 2 or 3 arcade games and they show kids shows on a big screen TV. the place is staffed by a whole bunch of teenagers so service is hit or miss.
… more
raymond peek
Lucky to get one star. Horrible service by one of the waitresses. Salad bar was empty said wasn’t her job. She just had a snotty attitude all night while we were there
… more
Jay Warner
I’ve eaten there for years and have known the family that owns it for years. Great food Great friends and a nice place to hang out.
… more
… View more