Based on 323 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
2709 E Newberry St, Appleton, WI 54915
Phone: (920) 734-4472
Website: https://www.facebook.com/The-Wishing-Well-119644321380908/
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–2 AM |
| Friday | 11 AM–2:30 AM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–2:30 AM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–2 AM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–2 AM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Glenn Sokol
This was a great place! Kara was truly “the friendliest bartender.” The food was really good. The atmosphere was nice and the karaoke was great!
… more
Pat The Head Gnome
Classic Friday Night Fish Fry. Staff is most excellent.
… more
Linda Huss
Food and server/bartender (same person) were awesome! Most of us had the chicken dinner, 1 had a burger. Everyone was pleased with our food. We sat at the back of the place unfortunately it was unlit except for the light through the windows as the sun went down no lights were turned on. We do plan on returning but will go earlier in the day! Lol!
… more
Suzanne Prieto
After 8 years, I finally tried the wishing well. It was Friday around 5 and the place was packed! It was mostly just people drinking, but there were a few groups there for Fish fry. There was one table left and we got it. Had to go up to the bar for drinks and to place food order because they were so swamped with the bar crowd. Old fashion was delicious. Ordered cheese curds as an app and that was quickly dumped at the table. We had to napkins, plates, silverware or dipping sauce for curds. Oh well. Fish fry came and it was hot and served with fries and slaw. Had to ask for tartar sauce. Overall, it was fair. I probably won’t go back but it’s good for the party crowd to get a cheap fish fry in before drinking all night.
… more
Anthony Collins
Excellent Fish Fry!! Great bartender bustin it! It was busy and she was pulling triple duty.
… more
T B
Nice place to meet with my buddy while I’m in town. Good food and good drinks.
… more
Kelly Miller
We dined here on a busy Friday, so slow service was expected. We were not prepared to encounter a combative server. “Michelle” got our order wrong and proceeded to raise her voice and argue about it. This, combined with her yelling profanities at us as we were leaving, created a very uncomfortable environment for the rest of the patrons. Very unfortunate and embarrassing for such a well-known Friday fish fry.
… more
Bree Vieau
I go there for taco Tuesday. And idk how they stuff these tacos so much without breaking the shell. But it’s amazing!!!! Plus the bartenders are super friendly! The crowd is always very nice as well
… more
Dan Meyer
When I arrived at the bar I wasn’t sure it was the right place, it barely helped to look at the sign it’s so old and faded you can barely read it, the parking lot is so disorganized so that with 20 signs on the north and south side of the parking lot could double it’s capacity.
… more
Bailey Lawless
Cold beer, great fish and shrimp, great price! Go early on Fridays to avoid a wait
… more
… View more