Relaxed eatery serving pizza & subs, plus wings, burgers, tacos & other casual eats. Based on 883 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1965 Seneca St, Buffalo, NY 14210
Phone: (716) 826-8406
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 10 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Stephanie Smith
I ordered delivery via the Slice app. I had heard great things. It took about an hour. The chef salad is enormous. Gluten free white pizza is surprisingly delicious. Regular crust veggies pizza also amazing. My only complaint would be they weren’t exactly hot but that’s fine. Will Def order again.
… more
Brian Dietz
So this is my first time here, we won a free large cheese and pepperoni pizza. I didn’t see oregano on it The pizza was decent, We also ordered a whole turkey club sub. It didn’t come with oil or pickles that we asked for. It was still very good and I really enjoyed the bacon on it. I did enjoy the arcade games inside the store. Our wait time was about 48 mins for our food. It also seemed that there was some problems at the register and a couple of the employees seemed to be getting upset. All together the food was good. I would try this place again. I posted pictures of the pizza and the sub
… more
Greg Estep
On a recent trip to Buffalo, we tried several different pizza places. Wise Guy’s Pizza was one of the places we tried and it was awesome!!! We went in for a couple of slices and the slices were so good that we ended up ordering two sheet pizzas to take home. The sauce is a sweet sauce and the crust is a nice medium thick crust. The cheese and pepperoni was very well proportioned, and the pepperoni used was the famous Buffalo Battistoni cup and char. A very nice blend of flavors from the sauce, cheese, crust, and pepperoni. Very tasty pizza! The owner was on site and provided great service. I would rate this pizza 9.2 on a scale of 10. If you are in the Buffalo area and love pizza, definitely give Wise Guys Pizza a try.
… more
Pranay Desai
We were driving by and picked up a few slices and garlic bread. It was hot and fresh.
… more
Kristina Weathers
I was told about this place months ago from a friend. I love pizza but I was never able to catch them open. Last weekend i finally caught them just as they were about to close hoping they might have some slices left. They did not but I was telling the young man that works there about how long i was trying to catch them open & i love pizza & this young man said hold on im gonna see if there is any slices in the back. He came back with almost a full tray of pizza & it was still pretty fresh. I told him i would take it, i asked him how much & he told me it was on the house!! I was amazed because its rare nowadays for that to happen since prices are sky rocketing, even for businesses. I tried it as soon as I got in my car & although I’m not particularly fond of sweet sauce, the pizza was really good!!! The sweetness of the sauce went with the rest of the ingredients.
… more
Erik Wollschlager
We love this place and we order every few months. Wiseguy’s sounded good on a random Wednesday, so we called in. Apparently, all of South Buffalo had the same idea because I’ve never seen it so busy, but I wanted to shout out the staff because they were amazing. I’ve worked in food service and know how tense things can get when you’re overwhelmed, but none of the people I spoke to showed it. The customer service was impeccable. And the food was great, as aleays.
… more
Dominic Drouin
Being a traveller from the Montreal region, I tried various Buffalo style pizzas in the last month and I must admit this is hands down the best in town! Lots of ingredients on the pizza. Cheese is delicious and the pepperoni is tasty.
… more
Michael Dodolak
Fresh and Hot.
… more
Eben Piazza
Service and pizza was good. The mafia thing is a little over blown but I liked pizza
… more
Crystal
I joined the online rewards program and it’s a bunch of BS. Twice I have ordered and have been unable to use any of my points. I have over twenty and everytime they have some excuse for why I can’t use them. They actually told us we have to call ahead to use the points, which sounds utterly ridiculous. Even when I complain in store they seem to be unable to do anything about it. The customer service here is awful. I have over 20 points! Yet I can’t use them. The food is good but there are many great pizza options in Buffalo. Today will by my last here. Very dissapointed.
… more
… View more