Based on 133 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
2105 Main St, Winesburg, OH 44690
Phone: (330) 359-5001
Website: https://www.whitmerspizza.com/
Hours
| Wednesday | 9 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 9 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 9 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday | 8 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 9 AM–8 PM |
| Tuesday | 9 AM–8 PM |
Reviews
Money Mike
The pizza tasted like Chef Boyaredd box pizza!!! I paid $35 for a boxed pizza!!! I read the reviews before I ordered and about how great the pizza was I guess they like a $6 box of Chef Boyaredd but don’t want to cook it themselves and pay over $30 for it…
… more
Krystal N
Stopped here on a trip through the Amish country. We ordered subs and they were amazing. Staff was very friendly. Was a very busy evening and didn’t have any trouble getting are order in a timely manner. Would recommend.
… more
Johnny Peña
Store was great very nice people.
… more
Joseph Vazquez
Perfect little store and tasty pizza while in the area for work.
… more
Jason Miller
If your looking for consistently good pizza this is your spot. Not fancy gourmet maybe but their crust is good as is their sauce which has maybe a tinge of sweetness. They also offer a good gluten-free crust. Also should add that they offer a massively large party size pizza if your looking to feed a crowd.
… more
Brian Rininger
I got a chicken club. It was okay but bland. Service was not good. We stood waiting a few minutes before someone asked my brother for his order. Even with a few people standing around. Immediately after she took my brothers order she left with me standing there. Didn’t say anything. Just turned and left. A couple minutes later, she came back and asked for my order. She then gave me the ticket for my order and left. Didn’t say how long or anything. Waited roughly 10 minutes for my order to be ready. She also didn’t mention either to my brother or I that we needed to pay up front. Never been here before. Most likely will not be back.
… more
Shelby Bellville
We ordered pizza for my daughter’s birthday party and everyone commented about how good the pizza was. It really was so good
… more
Diana Loane
Called to place the order. Older lady was rude on the phone. Didn’t say thank you or bye just hung up on me. Said food be ready in 30 minutes was over an hour. Didn’t even get the order correct. Wanted three orders of chicken wings and only got one. Had the pizza ready but forgot to make the garlic bread stix so had to wait on them. Glad didn’t get the 3 orders of wings cause the food was nasty. Didn’t even get I’m sorry or anything. Very rude and will never go back there again.
… more
Scott Smith
I am rating 3 stars because the food is actually good! The service though has seen a dramatic drop recently in my opinion. I come here a lot, I live right next to them and work 7-8 minutes away as well. Been coming here for over 4 years since I moved down here. Lately things are missing from my order, my order is usually late, and somehow a fresh burger made is cold when I get it. I waited almost 10 minutes past the time I was told to come, the burgers were forgotten so I waited. I live 3 houses away, so 30 seconds if even to get home and they were cold. Please understand everyone, I like the food and I will continue eating there. I still recommend other people go there. Just recently in the past couple months these issues are quite frequent. Nothing more frustrating than waiting after being told a time, a time they control, and then you get home or back to work and food is missing. I would rather be told 45 minutes and it be ready, than be told 30 and wait 10-15 minutes.
… more
Heather Miller
They have delicious pizza!
… more
… View more