Whistle Stop Tavern Menu – Carthage, NY

Type : Bar & grill

Location : Carthage, NY

Based on 121 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery

Whistle Stop Tavern 13619

Address:
33926 State Rte 3, Carthage, NY 13619

Phone: (315) 493-0304

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Thursday 3 PM–12 AM
Friday 3 PM–2 AM
Saturday 3 PM–2 AM
Sunday Closed
Monday

(Labor Day)
Closed
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday 3 PM–12 AM

Menu

Bar Toppers
Al Nacho
Chile con queso, yellow corn tortillas, all the nachoey goodness (fresh tomato, red onion, jalapeno, green onion, black olives, salsa and sour)
$10.00
Wecked Fries
Crispy crinkle cut French fries tossed in kosher salt and ground caraway, local cheese curd, shaved Angus prime rib, house gravy, horsey sauce and green onions
$12.00
Wings & Things
Bone-In Wings
Order of 10 tauced in your favorite flavor served with ranch or Blue cheese and fresh veggies for dipping
$7.00
Boneless Wings
Whole or half pound tauced your way and served with ranch or Blue cheese, fresh veggies of course
$7.00
Noon & Night
Chopper Salad
A hybrid mix of Romaine and Iceberg, crunchy and green. Plum tomato, red onion, English cukes, crumbly Bleu, crispy banzos and smoked pickled egg
$11.00
Beef On Weck Sandwich
Shaved prime rib, sharp Cheddar and horsey sauce on a Kimmelweck roll. Served with choice of side
$12.00
Sides
Fries $4.00
Rings $4.00
Pepper Mac Bites $5.00
Chips & Queso $6.00

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Ben Sayre
Was excited to see it was open again. Rodeo burger is great, with a different golden bbq sauce. Great service and highly reccomend the wings as well!

… more

Carol Swem
The King Burger was sooo good, also the Captain Nemo. Side of chips and queso

… more

Jazmin Garcia
Amazing wings and such a great atmosphere to be in with friends and to drink! Staff is always friendly!

… more

Ben Vallejo
Burgers, pizzas, wings.

… more

Sean Dardis
Friendly staff with fast service. Had The Classic Smash, and very glad I did, along with draft beer that tasted like it came from very clean lines. Friendly locals (staff and fellow customers alike) kindly greeted this out-of-town face and made for that much more of a nice experience. Will gladly drop in again next time I’m in the area.

… more

Rebecca M
Food was okay. Seemed understaffed. Bartender seemed to ignore/forget about us while talking to her regulars. She was friendly enough, a nice bartender…not too great a waitress. Which was okay, most people go to bars to drink…not eat. I was just passing through for dinner before camp, can’t complain much.

… more

Megan
Food was great! Service was fantastic as well. Don’t remember her name but we were there on Saturday 8/21/21 around 1pm. I had the BBQ pork burger. The smoke on the pork shoulder was so good, just the right amount of slaw, and a super fresh bun! It was excellent! Allen had the Mamma Jamma burger which had bacon, peanut butter, cheese, and jalapeno jam. I thought that would be weird but it was very tasty! Haley had the 10th burger- American and cheddar cheeses, tomato, bacon, BBQ sauce, onion rings, and smoked pork and beans! It was huge. Both burgers were done perfectly and the buns, again, were super fresh and really good! We were so happy to find this place and will definitely be back!

… more

Ashley Martin
Nice little bar. First time eating from there and we LOVED it. Only downfall was we ordered BBQ fries and got plain. Will definitely order from there again though.

… more

Chris Gutowski
Food was average, except anything smoked. The smoked food you could tell was done on a real smoker. The service was bad unless you were on the bar level. Had to flag the waitress down three times, and they messed up the order as well. The music was powered by someone’s phone and everytime they got a text cut in and out. The waitress were not very friendly unless you were a regular.

… more

Derek Notz
I’ve been going to this spot off and on for 10 years.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions