Easygoing joint whipping up familiar pies, pastas & hot subs, along with breakfast staples. Based on 685 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
350 Whalley Ave, New Haven, CT 06511
Phone: (203) 789-8100
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Britt Snider
Wow. The food is so fantastic and the lady working the register was so darn nice. I came in during a dinner rush and she was very quick taking orders at the counter and getting orders to their people. The tables and booths are clean, and I like the plants in the windows. My pizza was so good that I didn’t want to stop eating. I ordered a small mushroom and spinach pizza with a side order of fried clams.
… more
Amy Gorsuch
Picked this place on a whim and got lucky! The pizza was hot, fresh, and amazing!! The chicken salad was LOADED with fresh, tender, flavorful chicken. Literally, it was a layer of chicken on top of the salad. I couldn’t even see the lettuce until I dig into it. Delicious homemade dressing and warm buttery bread. Friendly service with great prices! Good tap water, too!
… more
scharlene torres
I was introduced to Whalley pizza 10 yrs ago and was instantly in love. A Native New Yorker Bklyn,Bronx Harlem. I got PIZZA.. So this place got my vote. Well, here we are 10 yrs later. I was excited ,I’m gonna get back to this place and have a GOOD PIZZA..NOOOOO…
… more
Marilyn
56 years ago I was a senior at Southern Ct. State College, now a university. A friend and I took a two-hour drive to New Haven on a very rainy Saturday, specifically so I could see how the campus has grown and to unlock some fond memories.
… more
Lamaar Wright (Marty)
Whalley Pizza has been feeding the locals and tourists from out of town for over a decade the food is fresh hot and clean,the take out and calling to place a order is very efficient and the counter help treats the customers like family if you haven’t had the chicken and rice or Grill chicken salad also pizza pies from Whalley Pizza you do not know what you missing out on,what are you waiting for call now or walk in today your mouth and appetite will not be disappointed!
… more
Chris Dill
My top 3 pizzas in New Haven, i must have and try if your in town.
… more
Jillian Felice
Whalley Pizza is the bomb in has been the bomb for at least 20 years I say that because that’s how long I’ve been going there to eat I started going there when I first moved to the neighborhood and I took my kids kids now they go and take their kids is kids and now I take my grandkids but yes I love it it’s the neighborhood go to spot
… more
Jeff Scott
I’m new to working in the area and this place is incredible. Great food. The Steak and Cheese Sub is perfect. I’ve also had their chicken cutlet wrap and Cheeseburger Sub and they were great also. 5 Star Greatness.
… more
Valerie Lawler
We went to get our car fixed across the st and noticed Whalley Pizza. Didnt look like much but apon arriving we found and amazing little place. The waitress was sooo nice and the food was great!
… more
Everyday Life with Aisha
My favorite spot on the weekends to go get Grill chicken salad with Feta cheese,creamy Italian dressing and buttery bread. Plus a sausage and bacon pizza with Hot wings for the family. I love this place
… more
… View more