Based on 150 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
958 Demorest Rd, Columbus, OH 43204
Phone: (614) 754-1660
Hours
| Wednesday | 4–10 PM |
| Thursday | 4–10 PM |
| Friday | 4 PM–12 AM |
| Saturday | 4 PM–12 AM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 4–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 4–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Müs Chip
Yooo, dynamite pizza! Loved visiting this spot. The fellas that run it are real friendly and hospitable. You can tell they’re passionate in their craft. Really appreciate the option of having beef pepperoni, hard finding that for non pork eaters. Was very delicious, the crispiness of the crust and pepperoni was perfect. The sauce was really good too, more on sweeter side which I like. The pepperoni had a great spice to it, next time will add mushrooms after reading since other reviews. We also ordered a house salad, which was fresh and no soggy/browned lettuce, and plenty of cheese and dressing as well as a cookie pizza. Definitely eat that cookie fresh as possible, it hardens up quite quickly. I’ve tried around 6 different non franchise pizza spots here in Columbus since moving here in early 2023, would be confident to say it’s my favorite pizza here. I can see myself ordering a pizza for the wife and I every 2-3 weeks. They’re building up this shop and putting in arcade machines for it’s patrons. It’s tucked away in a corner plaza where you wouldn’t expect this treasure, which is usually how it goes huh?
… more
Nick Saint
Been going there since day one. Hands down the best pizza in all of Columbus Ohio. They treat you like family. Everything they make is absolutely amazing. From pizza,subs,salads, Cheesey Bread even wings on Thursday.. I highly recommend Westside Slice to everyone I know ..
… more
Joseph Foster
This is good pizza. Easily the best pizza I’ve had from the west side/hilltop area. Sauce is unique. It’s kind of spicy/tangy. The toppings were good but the crust was very thin & crispy without being burnt, By far, the best part of this pizza. The major flaw is that they only offer 1 size of pizza, 14 inch. Hopefully they will fix that. Overall, I’m pleased with this pizza and would get it again.
… more
ty garrett
I wanted a pizza tonight and googled pizzas on the hilltop area in Columbus. When I saw that it was a new place I just had to try it out. Well I can tell you that this pizza shop has only been opened for six weeks. I was looking for a everyday pizza, but no, these guys took me on a journey that I haven’t been on in years. They served me a meat lovers pizza and a chief salad.
… more
MRBARBQ 1
Happened to be on the Westside and decided to check Westside Slice. A new business in the area that has been open around 7 weeks. The owners are Danny and Tanya. Me I could go just for conversation with them. SUPER nice people. We ordered a half pepperoni and mushrooms, half turkey pepperoni and mushrooms. Crust is a nice thin crust that isn’t really hard which was perfect. The mushrooms are finely chopped. The pepperoni is thinly sliced. The sauce was the star though, the slightest of spiceness. A nice cheese on top. Yummmy!!!! Get out and check them out, you won’t be disappointed.
… more
Tammy Bowman
The pizza was good subs were good also. Next time I’ll request dressing on the side. Sub was a little soggy but great flavors. I do like the pizza. Extra sauce is a must. (For me) The young lady at the counter was extremely nice. Overall, not bad
… more
Brandi Jordan
Ordered the special pizza (the works or Supreme) it was great.
… more
monica johnson
I ordered for lunch Saturday and loved it. The pepperoni and cheese is good quality with a sweet sauce and crispy crust. I’ll definitely buy again. It nice to see people trying to bring things back to the Westside.
… more
Josh Arnold
Drive by this location often. When we saw a new pizza place was taking the place of another that had moved to a new location (it was formerly Bella’s Pizza), we were excited. Saw a post that tonight was Westside Slice’s soft opening. The owner and employees were all very friendly. The sauce was nice on the sweet side. Congratulations on the soft opening! Will try again!
… more
AUDRA MAXWELL
First time trying and I can say 100% I’ll be back! Crust was crispy, sauce was very good, with a slight kick/tang to it. Really love the fact that they offer pork-free alternatives (I got beef pepperoni but they also offer turkey pepperoni). Staff were so friendly and clearly have a passion for their work. Great local spot. Don’t miss out on thos one!
… more
… View more