Based on 203 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
99 West Ave, Saratoga Springs, NY 12866
Phone: (518) 581-9999
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
That Chubby Dude
Great little pizza place. Nice big slices and a great drink selection. Grab a slice and a Manhattan Special or order take out. Can’t go wrong!
… more
Isaiah Stanley
We typically order for takeout towards closing. This is one of the few places that is willing to take orders at closing. The crust is always very high quality and the pizza is pretty good. The restaurant is always clean inside and the service is always very good. I placed an order incorrectly online recently and they made me fresh pizza right at closing. You can tell everyone there really cares about their customers.
… more
Susan Black
As a small business owner myself, I have hesitated to write this review, but ultimately I feel like the company needs this feedback. While the pizza itself is really good, the wait time is absolutely ridiculous. Every single time we call in an order, are told a time and… it is always another 20 minutes after we get there that the food is finally ready. Last night was especially annoying. We had a family dinner, were told it would be an hour. My brother went to pick up and there were so many people waiting. It took an additional 35 minutes to get the pizza. We had called the order in at 7 and did not end up eating until 8:45. It is pizza–it should not be this complicated. He actually heard that they stopped taking orders at 7:30 because they ran out of dough! Unfortunately until this issue gets completely fixed, we will not be going back, no matter how good the pizza is.
… more
TheLawrence Homestead
What a hidden gem. Exactly what you expect of a pizza place but more! Compared to surrounding shops this place is inexpensive. Staff is extremely friendly and service is fast. I was surprised to see how extensive their menu is for a pizza shop. Highly recommend
… more
Jennifer Blanchard
Ordered at 5:11 tonight via the Slice app. Estimated delivery was 6:32pm. 12 cut square pepperoni, an order of boneless wings and garlic knots. 6:20 I noticed the app said its on the way. Waited until 7, called and spoke to someone who wasn’t friendly and acted as though I didn’t understand how delivery works. They told me they send it as soon as it is done and sometimes the app just says it’s on the way by itself even though they have to do it manually, at least that’s what I understood, he was mumbling and huffing as if annoyed. Wings were so cold they had to be reheated. Garlic knots were just warm. Pizza is barely warm and extremely spicy for some reason. I have had West Ave pizza several in the past few months at work, it has been phenomenal. Not sure why it is so bad tonight. Disappointed and will order from elsewhere in the future.
… more
Sophie Dayyy
I’ve ordered to go twice now and it’s been 10/10. I never write reviews but had to for this place. The food is so tasty, serving sizes are big (leftovers both times) and price is great! Not to mention, it was quick! Best chicken parm I’ve ever had. Wings and pizza also great.
… more
Alicia Legg
West Ave Pizzeria made our son’s graduation party a HUGE success.
… more
Mary A
Called and ordered their Monday $18.99 special based on a mail coupon. Was told that the wings rhat
… more
Cory Burnett
We had the spinach white specialty pizza, it was some of the best pizza my partner and I have ever tasted, the crust holds up well, no sogginess there, and the toppings were of high quality, there was little to no grease dripping off when folded up and ate. Just some really great pizza, the chipotle citrus wings were lacking in flavor but the wings themselves were also great so I won’t complain too much about that, just advise to go for a different sauce, they also added a big cup of spiced up blue cheese without is asking for it that was delicious, especially with the pizza crust!
… more
A
Won a gift card during Chowderfest and was already ordering pizza for Superbowl so we decided to give them a try. Granted it was Superbowl, but we called at 11 am for a 5:30 pm pick up. when we went to pick up the pizza the order wasn’t ready. The pizza hadn’t even been made yet. We did not get our food until 6:30. If a restaurant is going to take orders for Superbowl there needs to be a cut-off if they can not accommodate all the orders in a timely fashion. The wait wouldn’t have been as bad if the food was good. The wings were dry and cold. The pizza was just barely cooked and was so soggy and floppy we had to eat it with utensils. I shouldn’t be able to roll my pizza up like a crepe to eat it. There are definitely better pizza spots in Saratoga.
… more
… View more