Based on 36 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
Address:
2880 Grand Ave, Baldwin, NY 11510
Phone: (516) 223-5925
Social Profile: 
Reviews
KrystynasWorld
The Wander Inn is a hidden treasure on Long Island that you shouldn’t miss. No matter what you order, it’s delicious. The house salads and Caesar salads are always crisp and fresh. Every appetizer is delicious, but do not miss the baked clams. The sauce alone is scrumptious – be sure to ask for extra bread to mop it up. Every main course we’ve had is fabulous – and the specials are always excellent. My husband loves Prime Rib night while my favorite is Lobster night. Be sure to save room for dessert – but it won’t be easy. Generous portions so there are always leftovers for the next night. The wait staff and bus boys are attentive and excellent. Go tonight!
… more
Anne Steinberg
Our favorite place for Italian food. Love Sal’s pizza with everything on it. The mussels are the best. Try the prime rib. The price is fantastic and it is so, so delicious. Wednesday is pasta night. Anyway you have it, it always comes out great.
… more
Kathie tinucci
The Wander Inn has a menu full of delicious meals and also a daily specialty board that never disappoints! The atmosphere is relaxing and the staff is very friendly. The Wander Inn is not only a family restaurant but also offers a great catering menu!
… more
Lee Rosentraub
We celebrated our 55th Aniversary at the Wander Inn. The meal was excellent and the service Was perfect!
… more
Barbara Garrett
The Wander Inn is a one of a kind gem located in Baldwin.
… more
Ying Lee
I came back to Wander Inn with different friends at different times. Each time the food was great especially the baked clams. They couldn’t stop talking about them. Great food which is why Wander Inn is one of my favorites.
… more
B Calder
Worth the trip via near or far .Old italian restaurant hidden off atlantic avenue in baldwin. Nice atmosphere,could use some updating but…… Service is exceptional and most food dishes are very good. Baked clams are OUTSTANDING ! And they give you a lot. Shrimp also is fantastic. Good sauce to go with their many pasta ,etc. dishes. We can’t wait to go back..
… more
Nancy Capozzi
It’s ALWAYS a guaranteed good meal at the Wander Inn. I have diet restrictions and they ALWAYS accommodate my needs, no matter how strange they are. Warm and friendly atmosphere. Our favorite hometown restaurant.
… more
Neil Hecht
Authentic Italian food in the heart of Long Island. Waitstaff is wonderful and they accommodate you in every possible way. The Lobster tails were so fresh! One of my favorite restaurants in Nassau.
… more
Jeff Finkelstein
Had my son in from the Marines with girlfriend from Michigan. Asked where he wanted to go and he said Wander Inn and it was a great choice service and food excellent. Would recommend for everybody to give Wander Inn a try you’ll love it.
… more
… View more