Based on 76 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.8 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
406 Main St, Boonton, NJ 07005
Phone: (973) 334-3400
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9:30 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: vinniespizzerianewjersey.com
Reviews
Jia Guo
A reasonable pizza place. My son likes the Sicilian pizza with sausage topping.
… more
Chuck Mound
I know a lot of Vinnie’s in the world of Pizza, but there is only one master chef Mickey Chopra and he has managed to deliver a great slice of Pizza on the great Main Street in Boonton. So much so that I think he should change the name to Chopra Pizza. He is the first Indian Chef that I have ever met that has made Italian Pizza. His Passion for Pizza is off the Charts. He could not show me his creations fast enough. Valentines Day Heart Shaped Pizza all made with Chopra Love. His thin crust slice screams Fresh, Fresh, Fresh with each bite. The Tomatoe sauce has a very distinct flavor that separates it from others. This could be because he is also the creator and innovator of the Indian Fusion Restaurant located right next to the Pizzeria. It is a mild blend of Indian and Italian. What? I just stopped for a slice and was hit with so much more. Will have to come back for sure to experience this another time, but the slice is worth stopping for. Fresh ingredients and made with love and passion, what more can you ask. Mickey is a character and is willing to talk to his customers about pizza and food. Did I already say off the charts? I cannot wait to go back and get some more video of the Rock Star Mickey. Not only is his Pizza Good, he welcomes you and places the higest value for each customer that comes through the doors. We will be back soon… great job.
… more
Jason Jacob
Legit truly hybrid options! We had the tikka chicken masala pizza and the chicken makhani penne alla vodka – both were great! Truly fusion dishes as you get both the Indian and Italian flavors coming through! This place is a must try!
… more
Leyla Demircan
I wish there was an option for ZERO stars. We ordered a large plain pie. The price on the printed menu means nothing. The owner is a scam artist…exactly how many of the pervious people that left reviews described. I WISH I HAD READ THE REVIEWS FOR THIS PLACE BEFORE STEPPING FOOT INSIDE. He makes up prices on the spot. Horrible experience, horrible food. Look elsewhere.
… more
Maia Blanco
I got a (reheated) slice of cheese and Buffalo chicken pizza, each. The cheese pizza was soggy and tasted a bit undercooked, flopped over when I picked it up. Tasted fine. The Buffalo slice was alright. Note, this place has the same owner/operator as i2i next door. They both charge 4.5% extra if you pay with credit/debit card, but the owner did let me know when ringing up.
… more
WhyUsername
Great pizza, friendly staff, good prices 🙂
… more
Joshua Vojt
Used to be an amazing place owned and ran by Vinnie himself, but they’ve sold and it seems they’ve sold the quality of the place as well. No longer your small town, home cooked Italian food, but it has all of the “small town” feel of Domino’s. We’ve been coming here for 2 years for everything amazing that it was, but unfortunately we will no longer return. Thanks for all of the great food, many laughs, and wonderful conversation! Good luck to the new owners
… more
Connie Ward
Our party of seven just left Vinnie’s and all were completely satisfied with our yummy meals! Both Italian and some specialty Indian dishes were ordered, and the sauces were very authentic and tasty. The BYOB is especially nice also. The owner assured that we had what we needed, and we definitely will be returning.
… more
Michelle Maher
My family and I decided to order from Vinnie’s tonight. Unfortunately, we were very disappointed in our meal. I ordered a plain/ pepperoni pie and we got a full pepperoni. We also order mussels,we asked for them to be hot. they just put extra Tabasco sauce in it and had no extra flavor. I hope the best but we will not be coming back. Definitely not worth the $30 dollars for a pie and mussels.
… more
J M
This place is terrible. Overpriced to start. Poorly made food. Out of 3 pizzas not one was sliced evenly in fact one was not even completely sliced. 8 dollars for a stromboli the size of a twinkie which was way overcooked and seemed stale. The cup of sauce was fresh, fresh from a Heinz jar. Far better options in this area. A first and definitely last for us.
… more
… View more