Longtime spot serving Italian fare in a casually elegant space with a full bar & occasional events. Based on 129 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
Address:
778 Montauk Hwy, West Islip, NY 11795
Phone: (631) 661-5599
Website: http://www.villamonacorest.com/
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Eileen Neelie
First time there – everything was great, ambiance, live music, delicious shrimp oreganato, great waiter too!
… more
J.V. Martinez
We used this venue for a baby shower and it went very well. The servers were all kind and professional. The food was well cooked and tasted excellent. The room we had accommodated 50 people easily and it was very clean. There is an ample parking lot. Absolutely no complaints and we had an enjoyable time.
… more
Slacktide
I always have a great time there. It is warm and cozy, the service is great (Ramsay is the best) and the food is always just right. I can’t think of a better local baked clam, fantastic Caesar salad, steaks are great as are all the Italian dishes (my favorite is the Chick Parm)…
… more
Martha Martino
Got married on June 15, 2018, also had rehearsal dinner the night before at Villa Monaco. It was absolutely Beautiful! The food was amazing, bartender was awesome, and the staff went over and beyond to make our wedding perfect! Friends and family have’t stopped raving about what a Great wedding we had, how great the food was and how amazing the staff was! Thank You Villa Monaco for making our Wedding and our special day Perfect! Michael and I couldn’t have asked for anything more!!
… more
Michael Granato
Excellent live music there the night I went to have a few drinks and appetizers, food is excellent, very nice dining room and bar area. Was also able to watch the ballgame while sitting at the bar. Bartender and wait staff provided good service and were friendly
… more
Heidi Harsch
Villa Monaco is our favorite local Italian restaurant. Our family likes to go there for birthdays and other celebrations. My kids love it as much as my husband and I do. We will be going there this Sunday for Father’s Day. Comparable to Patsy’s in Atlantic City but local and more reasonably priced. The staff is wonderful and the owners make you feel welcome every time!
… more
Tony T
Went there for Christmas Eve it was terrible. The waiter did not know what the specials are or how to explain them.
… more
Paul Mc Duffie
Nailed it again…
… more
Vane L (finessaa96)
The buffet was cold, didn’t have many options either. The food was nasty and it was undercooked because it ended up giving me awful stomach aches. Parking was small. Never again. The water tasted like old dishwasher soap and the soda tasted like it was expired with a mixture of old dishwasher soap.
… more
Shanna Gomez
Super friendly and attentive staff. Made us feel like family, especially our 3 year old daughter. Food was fantastic. We will definitely be back
… more
… View more