Compact, veteran, no-frills eatery with American classics plus fresh mussels & clams. Based on 463 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
2109 Montauk Hwy, Brookhaven, NY 11719
Phone: (631) 286-9569
Website: http://varneysrestaurant.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday | 11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | 11:30 AM–8 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Anna Lee
Had a wonderful time at this little gem after strawberry picking at Glover Farms. The fish sandwich was terrific and the atmosphere was quaint. The service was kind and attentive, and informed us this place has been around for 42 years! We will be back!
… more
Justin Saper
I have been eating at Varneys since I was a little kid. My mom loved the French Onion soup. Now, I take my family and we all love it. The food, the staff and the coziness. Lobster rolls are a must
… more
Steven Wilson
Nice little find in Bellport. Came in with party of 4 – their website does not say anything about reservations, but definitely call and make one. Service started out a little slow, but super friendly with helpful recommendations. We had the lobster rolls (hot with butter), Philly steak sandwich and fish tacos. The lobster rolls went over well and fish tacos got two thumbs up. The Philly was more like a hot roast beef and was good, but a little too heavy on the gravy – made it feel very heavy. Three of us went for dessert – rice pudding and mousse. All seemed to enjoy them. The atmosphere here is fun and friendly. Prices are OK – a little on the higher side, but not crazy – lobster rolls going for $36, but that’s MP I suppose.
… more
Yvonne Yang
Steamed seafood on a bed of linguine and freshly toasted bread was absolutely delicious! Friendly and fast services too.
… more
Steven Ganin
We have a mission to find the best Lobster Rolls, which we are big fans, and Varney’s has taken over the top spot. It was a 45 minutes drive to Brookhaven and was not disappointed. We started with 6 delicious baked clams and ordered an overstuffed lobster roll, French Fries, coke slaw and a pickle. The Lobster Roll was made to order and asked for ours to be served cold with VERY little mayo. We also had a choice to have a warm lobster roll with butter for those who prefer theirs warm. The owner, Catherine was supper friendly and very accommodating and would recommend trying Varney’s for a GREAT Lobster Roll.
… more
N S
We were in the area and found this gem, very low key, good food, good service, good drinks. The lobster roll was very good but I really enjoyed the baked clams.
… more
Crystal Monaco
The food is delicious and it is always a good experience eating here! The baked clams are one of the best I have tried and the hot lobster roll is delicious!! Sometimes it can be too buttery so just tell them not too much butter and all is amazing! Great price and service!
… more
Jeff Miller
great little place
… more
Chris Williams
Love the small community country type of ambiance. Service was a little slow but it is not a fast food restaurant which is great and they were very busy. Everyone including customers were very nice. I would definitely go back and recommend
… more
Rachel S
Ordered take-out here and while the service was slow, the amazing Lobster Roll helped make up for it. You can tell that the staff really care about the people and the business!
… more
… View more