Based on 161 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
7 N Beverwyck Rd, Lake Hiawatha, NJ 07034
Phone: (973) 263-2022
Hours
| Tuesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–10 PM |
| Monday | 10 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jayden Carrillo
Ordered a Plain Pie, it was a bit too cheesy – and not the good way it like a lol. I’d recommend to ask them to thin the dough out.
… more
Lauren Ann
I’ve ordered delivery from Valentino’s a few times and every time, it’s been a wonderful experience. They will call me right away with any questions to ensure my order is outstanding and whoever calls is always so nice. You can tell they want to make sure the customer is happy! Their delivery associates are always really friendly. Of course, the food is delicious!! It’s like a little trip back in time when I get food from Valentino’s- back when many proprietors truly cared about getting things right and taking pride in their business. Not to sound embittered or cynical about “these days” but sadly I’ve found that more often than not in society, there is apathy where there used to be a caring and solid work ethic. Valentino’s not only has this rock solid ethic but delivers (literally…bud-um-ching) a wonderful product. Can’t wait to try more of their menu items!! Grazie from this happy customer!! 🙂
… more
Chuck Mound
3/2021-5 stars .This is why you always go back to a place, every year brings a new experience. This place stepped up in 2021 with a Solid Margherita Pizza that was very very good. The regular slice needed more sauce, but the cheese and crust led the way. A very nice family owned small business that provides for its surrounding community. Add 2 stars for 2021.
… more
Deborah Berlin
We did a large takeout order and they had everything ready when they said it would be, they helped us bring it to the car and it was all delicious! Loved by kids & adults alike!
… more
Sean Hall
Good prices, friendly staff, and excellent pizza with prompt delivery and excellent attention to detail! One of the best choices for Pizza in this township.
… more
Fadi Batarseh
Order from here often. This time, we dined in. Love the staff, and food. We didn’t care for the chicken parmesan, however. Chicken appeared to be frozen, not fresh cutlets. Shrimp parm was good, but I bet it was also frozen. Their sausage pizza is the best!
… more
Chris Rivera
If I could pick 0 I would I order a. Chicken parm and got a veal than was told they couldn’t change it so I had to order and pay for an actually chicken parm paid $60 all together for them to give me what I wanted while they smile and take my money all I wanted was a chicken parm
… more
April Kushner
Clearly depends what you order here. I asked for a side of vegetables with the chicken parmigiana and I’m not sure what I got. I guess I was expecting broccoli, carrots, green beans? I had to pick off all the tails of the shrimp in my shrimp primavera but the sauce was good though.
… more
Laura Pflug
Always great food and great service! I’ve been a customer over 20 years. We have tried other places, but still come back to what we think is one of the best around.
… more
K D
It used to be the place to go for good pizza now it’s horrible they burned the pizza beyond belief it was un edible if this is the new way to be I’ll never go back pizza places are a dime a dozen these days
… more
… View more