We take pride in the fact that most of the ingredients of our dishes are made on the premises, from scratch, in the artisan, old fashioned way that we associate with homemade, great tasting food.
We believe in stability, consistency of purpose, and in the old practice of managing by walking around to ensure that our standards of food quality, presentation, cleanliness, and customer friendliness are consistently met all the time.
Family-friendly pizzeria serving inventive pies & oven-roasted sandwiches in a simple setting. Based on 404 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup
Address:
3740 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050
Phone: (305) 743-7100
Website: https://www.facebook.com/UpperCrustPizzaMarathon
Hours
| Saturday |
5–9 PM |
| Sunday |
Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
5–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday |
5–9 PM |
| Wednesday |
5–9 PM |
| Thursday |
5–9 PM |
| Friday |
5–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Frank Vvk
Because of long-time-waiting-to-be-seated in other restaurants, we decided to have a pizza at this place on a Monday evening in February 2023.
… more
Vanessa Hehl
This pizza was the best pizza I have had in a long time!! Highly recommend this little pizzeria.
… more
Scott Bernhardt
Got a carry out pizza. Just visiting and staying at Isla Bella resort down the road. Got the large pepperoni and cheese and a small cheese pizza for the little guy. Pizza was phenomenal!! Glad I choose this place. Will try the Italian next time.
… more
GJ Poore
Please give the Upper Crust a try. I don’t think you’ll be disappointed. Some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. Toppings from crust to crust. I ordered the Tuscan my husband got sausage and pepperoni with white sauce. We tried another pizza place and was so disappointed. $20 for a “10 pizza with 2” of crust. Topping were very sparse. We will definitely be back to the Upper Crust!
… more
Jennifer Snider
Pizza is not nearly as good as it has been during our prior Florida Keys trips. For the past several years, we’ve enjoyed Upper Crust pizza but all 3 of them that we ordered this trip were so dry and over cooked. We literally could not taste nor see any sauce.
… more
Wholegrain
Not many places get a 5 star review from me but this place does! Aton, maybe the manager? Not really sure…but I know EVERY time I’ve been there and she is there I’ve gotten amazing pizza! I’ve actually never been there when she wasn’t there so she might actually be the owner…not sure. All I know is this is the BEST pizza I’ve ever gotten (deluxe) and it is the BEST every time I’ve given them my business! Which has been 6 times now. 100% out of 6 times is enough to write a review I will definitely be back!
… more
Raegan Linster
We stayed at a hotel right down the road from Upper Crust, and one night we just really felt like getting pizza, but not sitting down anywhere. So we called here and ordered takeout, and they were super awesome! Their website is super easy to look at a menu, which other pizza places I did not find the same, and when I called the lady I spoke to was so nice, and great. And when we got the pizza half an hour later, it was really good!! The perfect dinner in! And we also had to nab a slice of key lime pie, and I thought it was pretty good. I wasn’t a huge fan of the sprinkles on top, I didn’t really prefer that extra crunch but the raspberry or strawberry drizzle was wonderful, a great touch. So yeah, if you want some classic good Keys pizza give these guys a try!
… more
Jason Nicholas
We had the Greek salad and Tuscan pizza. It was so great! Nice quiet place and great service. I will come back next time we are here!
… more
Micaela Farah
Best pizza in Marathon. The pizza crust was crunchy and it had a lot of cheese and toppings. The service was also exceptional.
… more
Amy Fusaro
It’s all relative! Wish I could add a 1/2 star. Should be 3.5 stars.
… more
… View more
