Undercover eggplant is a family-run sandwich shop specializing in handcrafted, homemade sandwiches, pizza, salads, and sides. All our menu items are served in generous, belly-satisfying portions. We are known locally for our homemade pasta salad and mouth-watering daily sweets choices. Come visit us, you won’t be disappointed!
Based on 570 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
421 Chestnut St, Oneonta, NY 13820
Phone: (607) 432-9900
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–7 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–7 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–7 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–7 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–7 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 11 AM–7 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Katelyn Thomas
Excellent sandwiches, pizza, and service. Great quality ingredients, good prices, nice location and business hours…….these are just a few of the reasons why this business has been so successful and enjoyed by myself and many through the years.
… more
Sean Lopez
Let’s start off by saying that this place is amazing! If you’re ever stuck in the rain or going through life, come on in and try their sandwiches! I had the “Oneonta Reuben,” and to be honest, I thought I was going to leave disappointed, but I didn’t!
… more
Susan Gillette
Absolutely love this place! The staff that runs it, truly gets customer service. The food is always consistently amazing. If you are visiting this is the place to stop at!
… more
Brittany Shultis
The home made bread for their large sandwiches is the best. One of my favorite places to go.
… more
Rose Wilson
I have NEVER left a negative review, and I am certainly someone who has frequented many establishments.
… more
Anne DeSimone
♥️♥️♥️ this restaurant. Lots of unique sandwiches. Delicious food. The garlic and eggplant pizza was fabulous. Very low key place. Will be back often!
… more
Breezy S
Went with friends who love this place but I was pretty disappointed overall. Ordered a salad first and took it to the house, it was pretty pricey but the ingredients looked fresh so I don’t mind paying for quality. Not sure how I could be disappointed with a salad but it happened. Nothing on it was seasoned, tons of extra ingredients that wasn’t on the menu that didn’t really go together, dressing was bland. I honestly couldn’t even really eat it, it felt like 2 different salads in one box, just eating the raw ingredients (I love mushrooms but don’t enjoy just eating them raw or with ther other ingredients that were on the salad). Went back the next day to speak to someone about it because I really wanted to like the food since my friends spoke so highly of them. Spoke with the chef and she was receptive but a bit cold as if I offended her which wasn’t my intention. Asked for suggestions on what to order and ended up picking a meatball sandwich since she said they made the meatballs in house. Got home and was surprised when I picked up the sandwich, it was completely soaked underneath. Meatballs were tough (overworked) and bland, marinara was flavorless, and it was served on untoasted sliced white bread which basically turned to a soggy mess. Hot foods + white bread= soggy. Then to top it off the sandwich was sitting on top of a pile of bland pasta salad adding even more moisture. Was a huge disappointment overall because they have such great reviews and the building was really clean and had a cool vibe to it. Great drink selection and unique menu but fell really, really short for me. **if you must use white bread try toasting the bread so it doesn’t get as soggy, or using a more substantial roll that will hold up to a hot food and maybe a sheet of deli paper between the sandwich and pasta.**
… more
Mallory Wagner
Great food, good portions. I really enjoy their pizzas too!
… more
Gloria Fischglo
Love this restaurant. I visit Oneonta, NY every two years. Lunch here is always on my list of fun things to do.
… more
Erie Steve
My girlfriend who worked nearby for years said that since we were in the area we had to stop here. I am certainly glad that we did. Our sandwiches were incredibly tasty.
… more
… View more