Casual, modern pizzeria offering a menu of creative pies, pasta & subs, plus beer delivery. Based on 482 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
616 Paxton Pl #104, Lititz, PA 17543
Phone: (717) 569-0906
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 4–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: uncommonpizza.com
Reviews
Wanda Ivette Colon
The drinks are not that great.. You usually don’t taste the liquor in the drinks. But everything else is good. They need a little more taste to the Pasta. Chicken wings and pizza, they’re good.. I think if they would put a little more love to the food. I think the taste will be good.
… more
Reed N.
This place used to be an absolute gem. Lately the service on all fronts has been just about awful. Extremely long wait times for both in house and takeout. Ordered wings tonight and walked to the restaurant since I’m local, waited just shy of 20 minutes (30 after placing my order) to receive my wings which were just sitting behind the counter for over 10 minutes. Unless you’re a regular and plan to be here 3 times a week, you get your food whenever they feel like it. Would be more likely to recommend Salt and Pepper over on oregon pike for a small place with great pizza. Seriously a disappointment here.
… more
Joel Henry
Tucked away seemingly in the middle of a housing development, this little joint is worth the hunt. The pizza was very fresh and tasty. Not a “thin and greasy” style of pizza, more of an in between pan and thin. The sauce, cheese and toppings had great flavor. I especially liked the crust, something about it tasted nice but I couldn’t place it.
… more
Tony Iz
Friendly staff, great atmosphere
… more
Laura Farbo
We’ve had several unfortunately negative experiences with their dispatch/delivery services- to the point where we don’t think we will be patronizing the establishment moving forward. The food was always consistent and good- so I am sad that it’s come to this. I cannot comment on the atmosphere as I have never been in the physical building. I wish them the best in this difficult market.
… more
Chris Thompson
First time there and sat at the bar to order a pizza to go. Bartenders were very attentive and friendly. Drinks were on point. We took our food home and it was delicious. Will definitely go back
… more
rafael roman
Ordered food for pickup. Small buffalo chicken pizza and a 12 inch buffalo chicken sub. Once home unwrapped what I thought was my buffalo chicken sub to my surprise a buffalo chicken cheesesteak. Called immediately at 7:39 was told a the correct sub would arrive 30 minutes later. Still no sub at 8:30 called again to be updated with its on the way the driver has it. At 9 the driver shows up with the saddest excuse of a buffalo chicken sub. Next to no buffalo sauce and poorly tossed together.
… more
Tom Hicks
We called ahead to order. Our food was ready when we arrived and they had a table reserved.
… more
char wilson
We have ordered from Uncommon Pizza a lot, and had always been satisfied before, but this past Saturday, I placed an order for my coworkers to be picked up by my husband at a specific time. I prepaid for the order, which was for four chicken Caeser salads, a veggie salad, and two large cheese pizzas. When my husband arrived, they told him they had never heard of the order, and didn’t know anything about it. He called me, and I told him what the order was for, and he related it to the manager on duty, who eventually gave him the food. After my husband dropped it off, two of the salads were missing dressing, and all four chicken Caeser salads did not indeed have chicken on them at all. I called the restaurant and talked to Matt, and asked for a refund for the chicken upcharge, and he asked for my phone number and said I was entitled to four free salads, and I told him in light of the trouble we had, It was unlikely that I would be ordering any time soon, and I would just like the upcharge for the chicken refunded. Matt said he would refund the four salads, and I said okay. Well, it still hasn’t happened, and I don’t like being lied to when all I asked him for was to do the right thing and refund the price of the chicken. As a result, I now doubt I will ever ever ever order from them again. I don’t feel that asking for a refund of the up charge for chicken that I didn’t get is unreasonable. They used to be so good. Now, not so much.
… more
Andrew Smoker
Historically great place, lately it seems like they are struggling with managment/prioritization. We waited for 1.5 hours for cheese pizza, fries and wings. Ultimately had to take it to go. Great service staff, good food. Banger option if you want take out.
… more
… View more