At Two Guys Pizza we always try to provide quality food quickly and at a fair price. From Specialty Pizzas and Subs to Wings we are always looking for unique ways to spin your typical pizzeria style food into an adventure. Be sure to stop in and try one of unique pizzas from our slice case on a daily basis and feel free to give us an idea for a new one and you may find it in the slice case in the future. Be sure to try our Stuffed Peppers and our “Pocket Taco” and you will see why people keep coming back for more. Dine-In, Pick Up and Delivery available.
Based on 288 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
3987 Walden Ave, Lancaster, NY 14086
Phone: (716) 896-4897
Website: http://www.twoguyspizzas.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday |
11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday |
3–8 PM |
| Monday |
11 AM–9 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jeff Williams
Thought i would try out since ive driven by for years. Pretty quick service, not bad prices. I had taco pizza and mushroom onion as thats all that was available at the time. They were ok slices, ill probably continue just driving by next time
… more
the robert
I dont usually do reviews but this was some of the worst food Ive ever had. We ordered Pizza, stuffed peppers, and pretzel bites from there last night. The peppers were kinda tough and filled with some gross wet stuffing. Took one bite, threw them away. Then there was the pizza. None of us had eaten all day so we all ate one piece.The sauce taste like it was straight canned generic tomato paste and had no flavor. The toppings gave it some flavor, but was too much. Everyone that ate had indigestion after and my stomach was turning for the rest of the night, burping up that awful taste. All around it was one of the if not the worst pizzas I’ve ever eaten and we threw most of it away. Gas station pizza would of been a better choice and I wouldn’t of spent over 60 bucks on it.
… more
J. Phillips
Haven’t tried many of their menu items, but it’s my go-to when getting lunch at work. Steak Hoagie is usually spot on. Assorted sub is good too. They don’t mind substitute the meat. I always swap the capicola for turkey
… more
Poppa Merritt
They have great food and a very clean place. The staff is super friendly and the quality never drops. Try the General Tso’s Pizza it’s to die for.
… more
philip cunningham
I have placed delivery orders twice in the past 3 months & I order 2-3 items to make it worth while to deliver them. It’s a whole 1.8 miles. I know the menu says prices subject to change & that’s fine but when it shows up it’s always $10 more than menu price. This time it was $32.10 but when it arrived it was $42.15. I know there are taxes involved but not $10 worth & if there is a deliver fee say so. Then the driver wants to look at you like you’re stupid because you don’t tip very much. I tipped him $8 the first time but only $3 this time. Sorry there’d have been more of a tip if the price wasn’t jacked up. I won’t ever order from here again.
… more
Exposing Powerful Lies; Livestreams
Love the chicken fingers and fries here. The Delivery guys are really friendly
… more
Joshua Allison
I travel for work so I try a good variety of places. I stop in here to enjoy some pizza before heading to the airport. The large was definitely large and it tasted a little above average 6.5-7 out of 10. The menu has lots of options to try besides the pizza as well. I got an order of the funnel fries and as you would except they tasted pretty on par with funnel cake from the fairs. My order was ready in a timely fashion as well. All in all would recommend.
… more
Austin Smith
First time here got the bacon egg cheeseburger sub and fries hit the spot everything on point and very friendly on the phone and delivery
… more
Dan Jonathan
Very disappointed. At 70$ for an order, Wings were Undercooked! We had to put the wings in an air fryer for over 10 minutes to make them edible. This place was good a few years ago. The quality has been going down. Gave them 1 more try, Last time we’ll order from two guys.
… more
shawn h.
There isn’t really much for food in this area so a sub shop / pizzeria is welcome. Food is pretty good.
… more
… View more
