Based on 192 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price
✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
1355 SW Gatlin Blvd, Port St. Lucie, FL 34953
Phone: (772) 446-9371
Website: https://www.twofatguysbrooklyn.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 8 AM–5 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
10 AM–6:30 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 10 AM–6:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–6:30 PM |
| Thursday | 9 AM–6:30 PM |
| Friday | 9 AM–7 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
F Peluso
Ordered two sausage and pepper sandwiches, they put it on a roll and had maybe one sausage in it. What a disappointment. I will never do that again.
… more
Diana Acevedo
Deli was clean. We ordered several subs. Everything was pretty good. My favorite was the meatball hero. Everything just needed more sauce. My mom asked for no cheese but they added cheese. If I order here again I would ask for a side of sauce.
… more
James Rivera
Coming from NY, this is the exact place I was looking for. We had two great sandwiches. This place is awesome
… more
Brandon Hhh
This adorable family run Italian deli is incredible!!! I stopped In For fresh cannolis and they were handmade right away ! The lentil soup is by far the best ever and vegan! The 3 bean salad with fresh beans, tomatoes, chick peas and cucumbers rocked and the marinated shrooms were also to die for for ! Wow ! Thank you guys for putting your heart into all this delicious food. Can’t wait to come back xo my son loves their Italian ice from NY 🙂
… more
Jaclyn O’Connor
Sandwiches here are AMAZING! Tried the #4 Bensonhurst and #18 Port St Lucie, both were delicious. Prices are also great. Will definitely be a regular here!
… more
Oscar Beltran
Our first time here was yesterday. It’s about a mile from our home so we see it daily and thought we’d give it a try. We’re an Illinois couple who moved down to FL 3 years ago and have been getting used to all the New York delicacies our area has to offer. I had always heard how the deli scene in New York is like no other and loved the ambiance of the store front, when you walk in you feel like you’re in Brooklyn. Great service, food options were yummy and plentiful. I think I need to do some research on how to order a new York sandwich or go in w a New Yorker because I feel like I could’ve done much better on ordering, I was overwhelmed to say the least. Get it hot or cold? Can I ask for other condiments? I don’t want to disrespect the chef or look like a dummy for putting something on a sandwich that shouldn’t be on there lol. I’m from Chicago, no ketchup on hot dogs type of situation. I ordered a sandwich which had a chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella and tomato on it and my wife had a salami sandwich which we both enjoyed. We ordered a rice and cheese ball and a cannoli and prolly the best cannoli I’ve had. Prices not too bad, we will be there again soon.
… more
Danielle Stephenson
I didn’t know what I wanted to eat, found Two Fat Guys and fell in love. When you walk in, they greet you and it smells amazing. The food was really good and looking forward to trying more things. PSL doesn’t have great restaurants, but this place is a gem.
… more
Robyn Ann
Loved the aroma of store and the food we bought. The fresh mozz, parsley and cheese sausage ring was quite tasty and the rice ball. My daughter had the Bensonhurst on semolina and raved about the bread. I had a bite or two and loved the sandwich.
… more
Mike Rivera
Sandwich was great and the frozen shells I bought were fantastic, Feels like a place in New York I use to go to, Smaller version , great idea for this town. small world..Guys just need to smile more. Nothing personal. Enjoy
… more
Christina Marsh
I dont know what’s better, the service or the food?!?!? I came in for tuna on rye but they were out so I asked if I could have a #24 but with eggplant instead since I don’t eat chicken. They didn’t hesitate to say no problem and it was AMAZING. The line moved super fast and everyone was extremely friendly and you can tell the food is made with LOVE. I absolutely recommend two fat guys!
… more
… View more