Based on 216 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Drive-through ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
229 McFarland Cir N, Tuscaloosa, AL 35406
Phone: (205) 248-2149
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 4–8 PM |
| Friday | 4–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
| Sunday | 4–8 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
La Ha
We were able to grab a pizza during a tasting. It was the best! Hands down best in the area for sure! The crust is not too thin or too thick. Fresh toppings and you can tell that the sauce and crust are made in house. Plus, super friendly service!
Swervin Optics
As an avid pizza connoisseur I finally tried TuscNY. For starters, get Kelly as your server(you can thank me later) she’s great! I chose the Sausage, Peppers, and Onions pizza Detriot Style with a Pesto drizzle. The pizza is great, very delicious crust, and sauce. Sauce is homemade and has a slight kick but still very good. Overall great experience, only downside is price. It is rather pricey pizza, I’ve had similar quality pizza for a less. I’d honestly try it again, but it hasn’t dethroned my No. 1 Pizza Spot. Therefore, it won’t be my first or second choice.
Erica Brown
My family could not wait to try TuscNY during our trip to Tuscaloosa and it did not disappoint! It was the best pizza we have ever eaten! Everyone working there was extremely nice and we had great, speedy service from Hannah, even though the place was packed. The crème brûlée cheesecake was amazing. We can’t wait for our next trip so we can eat there again!
Anastasia Reyes
Stopped by TuscNY while in Tuscaloosa and had their Bacon Chicken Pesto Ranch pizza with their Mixed Berry Tarte and Pistachio Cheesecake for dessert. All of it was delicious, and our waitress was so kind and helpful with any questions that I had:)
Bean and Bugs Mom
Delicious pizza with the freshest ingredients. Don’t skip dessert! Very comfortable atmosphere. Perfect for date night or a family meal. Everything was tasty! We tried the meat pizza and cheese pizza, New York style. Loved both. Will be back!
Mikayla Bailey
Not worth the insane price. The pizza is dripping in grease. You can’t even pick it up to eat without the toppings sliding off with the slip and slide the grease creates. I would have saved my $50 had I known what to expect.
Kristen Parker
The pizza is delicious here! The large, 20″ pizzas are worth it! Great atmosphere, service, and music was great! I had my birthday dinner here and they were very accommodating for our larger party. The mixed drinks could use a little work, but it’s a really neat restaurant.
M Langham
I saw this place months ago, but was unable to ever get a pizza due to the strange soft open hours and limited supply. The pizza was high quality. The restaurant is nice and clean. The sauce is the strong point as it seems homemade and delicious. The pizza had hardly any sauce on it and I like a lot of sauce. Luckily I asked for extra sauce so it was pretty good. There is a lot of crust, but they didn’t offer a side of sauce, so I waisted the crust. The cheese cake isn’t good in my opinion. Which is bad because you can almost see Southern Ale House from the parking lot, and they have “That Cheesecake”. The price nocked a star off for me as well. If the pie and a couple thin slices of Cheesecake were $45 or so it would have been 4 stars, but right at $60 doesn’t do it for me. Good clean restaurant, good service, quality ingredients, and the pizza isn’t bad. The price is too high in my opinion, might give it another try in a few months to see if I feel different.
… more
Sean Feely
If you like NY style pizza this is the place for you! Delicious and you only need one pizza to feed a LOT of people! There is also a cool little bar with no big crowd or intoxicated regulars (which is always a plus). Nice big TVs for watching sports so you can’t go wrong on game day.
Abraham Montes Salazar
Great place , the waitress was really helpful all the time , also the food is great , I will recommend the honey hot peperoni Pizza, Is not spicy as you might think, it has a sweet taste without been to over the top, it doesn’t over power the Pizza taste ,that is amazing .
… View more