We, Elton and Ashlea Allen, have proudly owned Trail Rider Pizza since 2006. We grew strong roots in the community in a small trailer down by Molly’s bar where we operated for 12 ½ years. In 2018 we relocated to the Triangle plaza where we built our dream kitchen. We put a lot of love and pride into everything we make. All of our ingredients are prepared fresh daily starting with our dough, made fresh every morning. Top it with our signature sauce made fresh. Next comes the whole milk mozzarella, grated daily in house; no pre shredded cheese is used in our kitchen. Finally top it with your choice of fresh chopped veggies, meats or vegan meat substitutes.
Based on 612 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No delivery
Address:
12165 NM-14 b2, Cedar Crest, NM 87008
Phone: (505) 281-6068
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Gerry Davison
Delicious pizza in a small town. It may have been the time of day we visited, the staff seemed a little overwhelmed. However we still got great service and delicious food.
… more
Tiffany Cameron
Delicious vegan pizza!!! Plant based protein options (AND yummy ranch). This was my first time at the new location and it was so nice sitting out on the patio with a beautiful view! I will definitely be back next time I’m traveling thru NM. Highly recommend. Great spot, great people
… more
Keri Schubkegel
This was our second time here trying their vegan items and it was an even better experience than last time! Our server (I think their name was Tenaya) was absolutely amazing! They were very helpful with choosing what to try and just so enjoyable to chat with. I also loved that they asked if we were vegan before telling us the specials for the day. We got the vegan green chilli cheese bread (size of a 12″ pizza so just be aware), vegan focaccia grilled cheese, and vegan cheeseburger pickle pizza (SO GOOD). They have a little baked goods section that is mostly vegan too! The vibe inside is also really fun! Can’t recommend enough!
… more
Ira Allen
Great meal, I had the vegan Enlightenment Burger, fresh greens, and mushrooms on in-house baked focaccia. French fries were hand cut. I would definitely order this again
… more
Ann Stout
Love LOVE this place! Food is amazing and fresh. Service is stellar and I love the vibe of the place. Fast service for great food. Had the green chile bread and meat lovers small pizza. Both amazing.
… more
Nate Peck
Great service! Great quality! We had Calzones and Loaded Fries. Both are great value, but the fries especially were much more satisfying than we were expecting! Don’t miss those!
… more
Doctor Wollenseuss
I’ve known the GM/Executive chef here at Trail Rider for years. Wherever he works, I follow him. Whatever the kitchen, whatever the style, whatever the trademark, that business will benefit from his uncompromising quality and unending creativity. The hallmark of this establishment, Pizza, is superb and fresh as can be. The salads, subs, appetizers (most especially the loaded basket of fries) are par excellance. The desserts here are enticing enough that I took one of each home. Beyond the kitchen, the foundation for the atmosphere is built when you walk through the door being greeted with a “welcome home.” I can’t wait to come back for the specials, considering today was a focaccia burger and shrimp po-boy, no telling what the future holds in store. Best addition to Cedar Crest yet!
… more
Michael Rowan
We love stopping by our customers stores and restaurants, and during a day trip from the city to visit the peak we knew we would be stopping here for Trail Rider Pizza! Glad we did, great location and service. So full from our appetizers, so we have some extra pizza for later! Great local crafts on tap, especially good is the Elephants on Parade for a unique taste
… more
Julie Quinn
Might honestly be the best vegan pizza we’ve ever had. Burger’s delicious, fries are great. I would seriously fly here just for lunch.
… more
olivier renard (FoxDeFrance)
Trail Rider Pizza in Cedar Crest, New Mexico, is a vegan haven! The array of vegan options is impressive, with a wide variety to choose from. The staff is outstanding, providing a warm and friendly atmosphere. Their homemade vegan pepperoni, sausage, and pastries are a delicious treat for any plant-based food lover. If you’re a vegan in the area, this place is a must-visit! It’s a vegan destination worth traveling to. Looking forward to returning!
… more
… View more