Best Pizza around! Why drive into town when you can get your Freshly made Pizza, Calzone, Pasta, Salad, Flatbread, Sub and the BEST Sweet Tea right here, located on 44 (Orange Ave.) just past the 44 By-Pass in Eustis. Come see us, we’d love to have you! Voted Best Pizza in Lake County by YOU! ~~Lake Magazine
Laid-back, homey hangout serving big portions of pizza & a variety of other Italian dishes. Based on 982 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout
Address:
2760 E Orange Ave, Eustis, FL 32726
Phone: (352) 589-9001
Website: https://www.tonyspizzandsubs.com/
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
sherry harms
Had p/u for veggie pizzazz pizza, fried pepperoni, baked cheese ravioli, and anti pasta. All was superb, but I wish the pizza had a little more veggies, especially the artichoke. Next time, I will ask for extra. The sauce was great. Found our pizza place.
… more
Bruce S
Tony’s Pizza & Subs says: “Laid-back, homey hangout serving big portions of pizza & a variety of other Italian dishes. With an extensive menu, we keep our customers coming back again and again. Eat in or carry out”.
… more
Tammy D
Try the fried pepperoni! Tony’s is a local favorite. I recently ordered 4 LG pies and 2 LG salads for a group. Everything was ready on time and as ordered. Their pizzas are unique and excellent! Thank you!
… more
Lin Wolf Lovo
I travel and not many places in Florida have the NY pizza taste.
… more
CHRISTIAN C
This was my first time ordering delivery from this establishment. Their procurement system is modern and easy to use via online. My order came hot,fresh,and on time to my hotel. They included utensils, which was a nice touch. The pizza was excellent. I recommend and will use them again.Thank you!
… more
Ron Mckinney
I have been ordering pizzas for the past year. Two weeks ago I ordered my regular order and when I returned home both pizzas were raw inside. I immediately called Kay, the owner and she apologized and credited me the two pies as she was training a new employee in the kitchen. I placed the same order today spoke with Katrina the manager. She stated that she only saw one credit. She would not call the owner ( Kay) to verify my credit ( told me that Kay was vacationing where there was no service ) and told me I would have to pay for the second pie, which I should have had a credit for. Katrina was very unprofessional and rude. Katrina was ” scripted” and continued to tell me she was busy and had nothing else to offer me at this time. Katrina stated that I could call next week and receive another credit for the second pie. I was considering using them to cater my son’s wedding rehearsal dinner, but because of their lack of professionalism and not standing by their word, I would NOT recommend them at all!!
… more
Ryan Long
It’s a cool little Italian place where the food is priced decent. I’m not a fan of l the asagna but every other thing I have tried is awesome. It’s a decent place to eat . I will be eating again
… more
Jerri Patterson
Wow, as if the pizza, Greek salad, and knots weren’t enough to impress us. They girls bring us dessert. All I can say is definitely save room for it. Super friendly staff, great food. Will come back again.
… more
Kenneth Birkhofer
Great little restaurant that has been providing excellent food and service for years.
… more
Grief Tactic
The fried pepperoni pizza definitely has pizzazz, the crunchy mouth feel was the perfect touch.
… more
… View more