The best pizza and Italian food in the Fort Myers area. Real NY pizza made by real NY pizza makers. Indoor and Outdoor seating is available! Join us for the best pizza in Fort Myers!
Offering Pizza, wings, strombolis, calzones, Italian Dinners, Pasta, Salads, Desserts, Soups, Subs, Beer, and wine!
Based on 563 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
3398 Forum Blvd #101, Fort Myers, FL 33905
Phone: (239) 931-7991
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Krystle Germanich
Nasty!
… more
ryann r
Love Love Love the pizza here. I am from Jersey and it just reminds me of home, the sizes of the slices are great. However, the prices are a bit high, almost 4 dollars for a plain cheese slice, that’s a little aggressive, and almost 5 dollars for one’s with a topping, way too much. Keep making great pizza though!
… more
Cynthia De Las Salas
This place is definitely a 3.5 stars if not some more. The service is always good, the food fresh and the servers attentive and knowledgeable about the menu. The actual place is a little crowded but clean… even the bathrooms!! And that’s rare for a place that is so crowded. Go hungry and expect the food to be yummy . #enjoy and the rest will be pizza history . We had the 14” Manhattan pizza with hot chicken wings and left there more than stuffed with a box of leftovers. It was definitely worth the $$. Hope you #enjoy it!!
… more
Amanda “Haute Hair23 by Amanda” G
Our experience was great! From the mommy we walked in to the time we got our food!!!! Our kids are now wishing we had one of these locations in St.Louis!! From the plentiful toppings to the cooked to perfection crust!!!! They definitely don’t just hire anyone to cook & you can tell! We ordered an 18in 1/2 Bronx 1/2 cheese! It was the perfect size for a family of 4 & the price point is awesome! They also sell by the slice if want to try a bit of everything
… more
James Smith (James N’ Games)
Tony’s N.Y. Pizza and was blown away by the quality of their food. The pizza was simply amazing, with a crispy yet chewy crust, fresh toppings, and a delicious sauce. It was evident that the pizza was made with high-quality ingredients and cooked to perfection in a brick oven.
… more
Leo Navarro
DELICIOUS!!!! One of the best NY style pizzas (without visiting NY) around! Tony’s rocks a variety of different pizzas with catchy names! From the “Bronx” (which I had) to the traditional deep dish Sicilian, there are plenty of pizzas options to choose from. The serving staff is pleasant and fast! You can pick from just a single (HUGE) slice to a whole pie. Eat in or carry out, you won’t regret either choice!
… more
Maria Vega
Upon walking in, the customer service was flat like the soda from the fountain drinks. The garlic knots were hard and had a lemon tangy taste. The pizza dough was good, but the pizza itself had no flavor. Never had unflavored/unseasoned pizza. Definitely not worth the price.
… more
Andrea Owens
The pizza flavor was good, but it was soggy, we couldn’t pick up the slice without all the cheese falling off. The waitress gave us an attitude as if we walked in 5 min before closing. Not a first good impression, I am not sure we would return, but I do wonder about all these 5 star reviews, maybe we just didn’t have good luck, or the people reviewing have never had an authentic NY pizza outside of Fort Myers.
… more
J N
Love Tonys Pizza. But they really surprised me when they charged me $2.14 for a can soda.
… more
Laurel Caro Esposito
The pizza was really good! We ordered slices! You can taste the difference between REAL pizza and the “others”. Our server was pleasant and the slices were served hot!! Highly recommend!
… more
… View more