Based on 176 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.8 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No delivery
Address:
3360 Sheffield Ave, Dyer, IN 46311
Phone: (219) 515-2012
Website: https://www.mytonysdeli.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed
Holiday hours
|
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–5 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–5 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–5 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–3 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Corinna Maggi
Nice Italian deli with basic fresh options and lots of shelf and frozen options that are either imported or made from scratch. We bought items to make a sandwich and took it home and ate it right away. DO NOT PASS UP THE TOMATO FOCACCIA. It reminded me of some the excellent sandwiches I would get in Chicago. We will definitely buy one every single time we stop in. I was tempted to try one of their fresh desserts but at $5 each I couldn’t pull the trigger. (Maybe I’m just ignorant to the going rate as I rarely buy fresh to go desserts.) But I’m sure they would have been delicious as they looked it! Owner (I’m assuming, or manager but definitely got the owner vibe) was super kind. We definitely come back to local places that treat you like family!
… more
Robert Lynn
My first visit and was very impressed. First, by the deli’s atmosphere and layout. Nice selection of Italian products, e.g. pasta, sauces, cheeses, etc. Deli counter had wide variety of tempting salads and meats. All products arranged beautifully. Menu is large and clear. Staff is welcoming and courteous and in very clean matching attire. The restroom was spotless. Now for the food. In a word, excellent. From someone born and raised in the Bronx, New Yorker, I know and appreciate fine Italian food. This is the place to get it. Even met the owner, Tony. Cheerful, friendly and was making sure everything was being attended to. Overall an exceptional and memorable experience. I’m a committed and returning customer from now on.
… more
tim z
I go there at least once a week. You actually get a sandwich you can find the meat on. LOL. Everything is fresh daily and tastes great. Sit around and socialize with the staff for an added bonus.
… more
Lisa W
Deli help was fantastic. An okay selection on groceries….you can get some basic specialty stuff. Owner seemed irritated to be there. I’ll def go back when I don’t want to go to the Heights.
… more
Maurice Harris
I dropped by to pick up desserts for a BBQ that I was attending. The staff is very gracious and the desserts were all unforgettable. Their cannolis and lemoncello tiramisu are not to be missed.
… more
Larry Nussbaum
I was recommended by a friend that they had the best Italian Beef period! Growing up in Chicago Heights I’ve been blessed with many great examples through my younger days! Moving to Munster there’s a couple places I like but today that changed! Tony’s was outstanding! The very best I’ve had in ages! I will be a repeat customer for sure
… more
Leah O
I like the meatball sub, which is in a league of its own. I’ve been wanting to try the Italian sausage sandwich and when I found out today that they make their own sausage, I decided to try it and it was fantastic as well. It was my lucky day because today the soup was Wedding Soup, which is a must have from there. The place is always immaculate and never disappoints!
… more
stephen Q
Great little deli saw the sign while driving by and thought I would try this place. I asked what they made that I wouldn’t find anywhere else and the ladies said try the Diavolo panini. Sandwiches were amazing the Italian susage was the best I have had. Staff was amazing and the place was so clean.
… more
Debra Meekma
Everything here is amazing, from the products, to the quality of the food, and the friendliness of the staff! The sandwiches were fresh and delicious and the cannoli is OUT OF THIS WORLD!! Don’t pass by this place, stop in today!!
… more
KAREN BARTZ
I went to Tony’s to get ingredients to make lasagna and they were very high quality. I purchased ricotta cheese, Italian sausage and Nonna’s gravy pasta sauce. I met both owners which were very nice and helpful and my lasagna turned out great!! I’m going back today to get sausage to make Zuppa Toscana. I highly recommend this deli.
… more
… View more