Based on 116 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout
Address:
885 E Ingomar Rd, Allison Park, PA 15101
Phone: (412) 364-6622
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 4–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 4–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 4–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
David Riggio
We had the tomato pie pizza and the beet salad. Both are fantastic. I rarely get a salad but I’d 100% order this one again. It’s a nice clean salad. The pizza just tastes fresh and not “wet” as white pizza can be with overloaded oil, grease and garlic–none of that here. The staff were all friendly as well. Well done!
Christina Schutzer
We stopped by after a day at the park and tried the signature pizza and the chicken salad (by our servers awesome recommendation). The salad was delicious, the even the pita was so flavorful and that’s coming from someone who doesn’t like bread normally. Get the signature pizza, but just know it will ruin all other pizza for you forever. We can’t wait to come back!
Jim McKain
Great place! Well kept secret also!
Daniel Hooven
Great food, wonderful service and beautiful atmosphere. Will be back for sure!
Steven Mongelluzzo
My family and I got there at 6 PM. We were seated at 6:15 PM onto a dirty table that had the previous people that were eating there still with their dirty dishes. The waitress told us to sit while we can, and she would be over to clean off the table at 7 PM. Our table was still not cleaned off, and we were still sitting there with dirty glasses and dirty dishes on the table. The waitress was an older lady with blonde hair. Who told everybody she was going to call off that night i sure wish she would’ve. The next waitress was a girl who was all of 16 years old, who kept telling us she was going to come over and take our order. At 7:20. She finally came over and got our order. We were not served until 8 o’clock and all we got was pizza place is filthy, dirty. Our pizza was cold and my wife’s spaghetti “tomato with basil “was ice cold!! at 8:20 I asked for a check and the young girl said I will be right out with it at 8:40. I went in the restaurant and demanded my check. I will never go to that place again. Horrible, horrible experience.
… more
Mandy Fister
What a peaceful and happy place to enjoy a high quality bite to eat! We sat on the screened in porch off the back of the restaurant. The pizza was so fresh and delicious. The tomatoes on the pizza tasted the way tomatoes should taste! Flavors are abounding and the beautiful garden that creates them surrounds as you enjoy your meal!
Alyssa Randell
Delicious food with home grown ingredients behind the restaurant. BYOB and cash only! I’m visiting from Florida and I was craving the beet salad, I went two days in a row. So tasty! Friendly staff and a cute atmosphere
Emily M
Some of the best pizza we’ve ever had! Our server told us they’re closed throughout the winter because they only use fresh ingredients from their garden. You can definitely taste the difference! It’s also BYOB and cork fee is only $5 🙂
Jason (PlayaFritz)
Great little place just outside of Northpark and an easy walk from the lakeside of the park. All of their food is great, but quite pricey. They have outdoor, indoor, and a psueodo indoor balcony seating. The place is usually packed and is only open half a year as a result. Try one of their signature pizzas coupled with a dinner salad!
M K
Inviting atmosphere, friendly staff and the food….I’ve been going to Tomato Pie for more years than I’d like to admit. The food is wonderful, when you’re looking for food that can satisfy whatever you’re craving, this is it!
… View more