Based on 267 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
530 Co Rd 515, Vernon Township, NJ 07462
Phone: (973) 764-4162
Website: https://tomatogardenpizza.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Lemakk7
I’m new to Vernon, I’m a Nyer. I’m trying to find my go to Pizza niche like Cascarino’s back in Whitestone NY. I wasn’t happy with my recent order at Garden Pizza, I was told my delivery pie would arrive in 1hour, it got here in 1 hr and 40 minutes. It’s not the delivery guy’s fault and the weather wasn’t that bad, but I just wanted to give my 2 cents. My pizza was cold upon arrival and I wasn’t given the 2 liter Coke I ordered, but I was offered a refund for the coke. Unfortunately I wasn’t given a refund for the 20 oz of Coke they put down, when I actually ordered a 2 liter Coke. Hopefully the service will improve soon, but we shall see.
… more
April Goode Bradley
I had a buffalo chicken wrap it was fresh packed with chicken and worth the purchase the delivery driver called ahead and gave his ETA which I thought was super nice. I didn’t add a tip when I paid over the phone and when I got my receipt there was no space to add a tip. I didn’t have cash and felt bad they should add a tip option on their receipts
… more
Kira Dowd
After placing an order for delivery at 5:15PM, and receiving our order at 8:45 when we were given an ETA of 1 hour to an hour and 20 minutes, we requested either a refund or a credit for the order and were told by Andre that this was impossible because if they refunded every customer they would be out of business. If you can’t deliver an order within three hours, then maybe you should be out of business. Also our order wasn’t even fully correct.
… more
Marc Fanberg
Best pizza place in town! The Spinach and Artichoke Grandma pie is my fav. Not only is the pizza delicious, but the service is also friendly and lightning-fast. Visit this place and treat yourself to the best pizza in town!
… more
Birute Spina
I did not like the food at all! The food had no flavor. The panini had no panini bread just a cheap Maier’s Italian bread or similar. The shrimp parmajan sub had no shrips! It was breaded imitation crab sticks you can get at supermarket! Sausage was bland! We did not get water at all!
… more
ken wasiewicz
Always a great meal. Reasonable prices and always consistent. Definitely recommend them.
… more
Edison Kastrati
The pizza was delicious, the owner and his staff were great. Definitely eating here again when im in the area.
… more
M.E. Swiss
Moved to this area 9 years ago and have tolerated the pizza because it wasn’t like back home. This restaurant has hands down the best pizza in Sussex county.
… more
Matt B
My family and I are repeat customers. The entrees and pizza at tomato garden, especially the Sicilian, is excellent. My wife and 2 boys had dinner in the restaurant tonight for Valentines day, we were very pleased with the service and our meals. There was a little problem with one of the entrees but the owner did not delay to make it right. They handled the issue very professionally and we couldn’t have been any happier. Thanks for the little bit of love you showed me and my family before we walked out the door.
… more
Tomasz Szast
Amazing staff and great pizza!! Highly recommend for lunch or dinner! It’s also BYOB.
… more
… View more