Comfortable establishment doling out Buffalo wings in addition to customizable pizzas & pastas. Based on 571 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
2309 W 12th St, Sioux Falls, SD 57104
Phone: (605) 335-8500
Website: http://tomacellis.com/
Hours
| Wednesday | 10 AM–9:30 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–9:30 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–10:30 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–10:30 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 10 AM–9 PM |
Menu
Photo Gallery
Reviews
sonia RS
The pizza at this place had a great taste, and the quick delivery to our hotel was impressive. However, I was puzzled by finding an open fork in the cheesecake box. Despite that, everything else was enjoyable, so I’m deducting just one point for that oddity.
Jay Allen
Vary delicious all meat pizza I would recommend this, we had it delivered to our hotel. Driver was super nice.
Joe Albergo
This place is fantastic ! I ordered from them while I stayed in Sioux Falls for a few days. I’m in love with the cheese and pepperoni pizza they make called THE SUPER PEPPERONI !
Tammy Jo Zingmark
We ordered for the first time in about 5 years. Ordered for pick up. Told 7:30 for pick up time. Arrived at 7:20, pizza was ready. Pleasantly surprised!! However, arrived home with a cold pizza! The cheese had already hardened, not melted and hot, crust was lukewarm. Not sure what happened but when you spend that kind of money for “hot” pizza and you have to microwave…huge disappointment.
Raquel
We went there for dinner as soon as we arrived from our long drive from North Dakota. We were starving for pizza. We looked up for pizza places as soon as we were 10 miles from arrival to Sioux Falls. Tomacelli’s was closest one as we arrived and was open on Mondays unlike others in town. We tried it and we weren’t disappointed. It was a small place but don’t let that fool you. Yeah it’s not one of your franchise type and more bigger and fancier establishments but we came for the pizza. We saw the many reward plaques hung on the wall. It’s like it’s family owned and the guy who helped us was accommodating. Good Old fashioned service. The pizza was excellent that’s all we can say. The crust was crunchy and just cooked to perfection. The toppings were fresh. Sauce just the right amount. It’s too bad we didn’t have a permanent marker to write on the wall. Many visitors have signed the wall. We would’ve signed it as visitors from out of the area. Great place for pizza and we will be back when we visit Sioux Falls again.
… more
Brandon Mays
Hole in the wall place but Absolutely amazing pasta and food… we went there a few days earlier for the pasta and we enjoyed it so much we decided to go back for the pizza!!!! Both were delicious!!!!
Eric Williams
Ordered 16” w/ green peppers and mushrooms for delivery. The guy on the phone also delivered my pizza and was super cool. Proper ferment and bake is evident on the dough, enough gluten to give it body and a bit of chewiness but without being tough. Toppings were fresh and plentiful. I’ve now had three Sioux Falls pizzas in as many weeks and #2 is distant to Tomacelli’s, the clear victor. Highly recommended.
Carol Stewart
This was a pleasant surprise. Hubby had pizza, I had chicken Alfredo. Food was delicious and owner super nice. Would definitely recommend! If you want a fancy place this isnt that but was clean and just a great place for good food and nice people.
R
One of our favorite pizza places in Sioux Falls is Tomicellis! Our go to dinner from there is the Spartichoke Pizza that comes with feta, spinach, artichokes, roma tomatoes, olive oil, and garlic. I highly recommend throwing some cholua on it for some extra razzle dazzle! If that’s not your style they have many other options to choose from along with pastas, desert, and appetizers. If you’re craving pizza and don’t want the usual franchise chains we highly recommend this local pizza spot, the one on the west side is very unique when you go inside but has a certain charm to it and somewhat reminds me of the old pizza places back when I was a kid, especially when someone is playing the arcade game up by the order window.
… more
S&B Johnson
It was our first time eating at Tomacelli’s. Both my Fiance and I loved the food. The writing everywhere was a little strange but interesting. Our waitress was super nice! The only down side to our experiance was the rips in the seats. Please patch things up! Overall will be returning!
… View more