Based on 199 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
139 E Main St, West Jefferson, OH 43162
Phone: (614) 879-9353
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 4–10 PM |
| Saturday | 4–10 PM |
| Sunday | 4–7 PM |
| Monday | 4–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 4–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Sara Johnson
Best pizza in West Jeff!!! Has that old school vibe with the 80s rock music, bar stools and squishy seats surrounded by vintage decor. Best thing was the food and service though! Free popcorn!! They are so kind, respectful and didn’t skimp on my veggies! Yum! Definitely recommend
… more
Vivian Thompson
Todd’s Pizza Restaurant in West Jefferson is a delightful small pizzeria that exudes a cozy atmosphere. Their Italian sub with double meat and cheese was simply outstanding. The Italian dressing was perfectly balanced, ensuring the bun wasn’t soggy. The attentive service kept my drink refilled throughout the evening. It’s a charming hometown spot that you should definitely visit during your travels.
… more
S.B. Hubbard
A nice small, cozy pizzeria! I had one of the best Italian subs, 12″ hot with double meat/cheese! Just the right amount of Italian dressing did not soak the bun! Just an awesome sandwich! Service was great, keep my drink full as I was rather thirsty that night! A hometown place with hometown folks! Check it out in your travels!
… more
Ryan Pontious
Came here with a group of six and our son and friend’s daughter. It was busy being around 6 on a Friday but we got seated fairly quickly. This place has all the makings of the old pizza shops you probably have fond memories of with an old school feel and friendly staff. Being our first time here we did our usual test of half cheese half pepperoni (if a place can’t impress with the basic toppings than that’s usually our last trip). This place passed with flying colors. The pizza was thin and light with a good crisp crust and the cheese, pepperoni and marinara were well balanced. We also got a chicken Parm sub that was equally good. We will definitely be back and would highly recommend.
… more
SH
Food was hot and delivered in a timely manner! Great service, as always! We got the BLT pizza. Can’t go wrong with that!
… more
Danny Stegler
Food and service always great. Italian sub and BLT pizza delicious
… more
Ashley Boggs
Pizza was great, kids gave 2 thumbs up. They loved the crust bubbles! I had an Italian sub and it was more then filling. Can’t wait to try more!
… more
Tammy Gonzalez
Everything we ate was Awesome!! We hadn’t been to Todd’s in years, and We live in Columbus and come to WJ on every other Wednesday Evenings. This is going to be our every other Wednesday, date night!! Thanks for the Great Service!!
… more
Ashley Roby
It doesn’t get much better than Todd’s pizza! The service is always great. We had a special order to avoid a food allergy and they went above and beyond to make sure our needs were met. The young man who delivered our food was friendly and even told us that he knew our order was in line with our allergy. We love the food at Todd’s. Everything is delicious and fresh. The prices can’t be beat. We frequently eat Todd’s and will continue to do so. We are so thankful to have such a great place so close to home!
… more
Angela Eaton
It is a great place to eat & relax after working or just running around
… more
… View more