Throwback Supper Club Menu – Elkhart Lake, WI

Type : Restaurant

Location : Elkhart Lake, WI

Based on 22 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery

Throwback Supper Club 53020

Address:
91 S, 91 Lincoln St, Elkhart Lake, WI 53020

Phone: (920) 876-3133

Website: https://www.facebook.com/Throwback-104103744704773/

Hours

Thursday 5–9 PM
Friday 5–9 PM
Saturday 5–9 PM
Sunday 4–8 PM
Monday Closed
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday Closed

Menu

Appetizers
Onion Straws
Meatballs
Reuben Puff
Shrimp Cocktail
Salads
The Wedge
Grilled Peach Salad
Entrees
Airline Chicken
Scallops Benedict
Tenderloin
Salmon Slider, With Veggies Or Fries
Throwback Burger, With Veggies Or Fries

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Ken Pannier
Cozy, warm atmosphere with nice decor. The grilled vegetables and beer battered shrimp were excellent ! French fries and cole slaw also great.

… more

Patricia W (Patty)
Our waitress Stephanie was very informative and helpful with the menu.

… more

Gus Johnson
This place has the service that families deserve while on vacation. We will be coming back, and I will be ordering onion straws as an app, pork belly stem buns while sipping a perfectly made Moscow mule.

… more

Mark Di Pietro
If you’re online looking for a great place to eat. You found it. Go here. The food was fantastic. Everything is fresh and made from scratch. Seriously everything. The service was amazing. The old fashioneds were done right. Plus look at this dresses up monkey decor! Go here!

… more

Lauren House
Excellent rib eye.excellent shrimp Homemade noodles. Omg.The whole meal and service was beyond expectations. WE WILL BE BACK.

… more

Amy Jennings
We came across this by accident and are very glad we did. Excellent beer menu and elevated dining menu. There even was one meatless dish that was grilled fresh vegetables and made the person in our party with dietary restrictions very happy. Schnitzel and mashed potatoes were really good. Relaxing atmosphere and excellent service. We definitely will be back

… more

Caylee Sparks
This is the best food around right now. Chef Adam is amazing and Shelly’s homemade pasta and desserts are unmatched. My chicken piccata was the best meal I’ve had possibly ever.

… more

Rachel Gilsdorf
Went for our wedding reception and was blown away! Everyone was super friendly and the food was amazing!!!

… more

Vienna Raglin
Throwback is an incredible Elkhart Lake must with a quaint ambiance for fine dinning and a cozy antique bar near a fire place. They have a dynamic, modern menu that has a unique deconstructive take on classic dishes with moderate pricing. I enjoyed Sals, then the Elkhart Inn and now, this is my favorite.

… more

Christian Fite
Great food and even better people! You will have a great time here because they are very talented in the kitchen and all the staff truly cares about the customer experience.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions