THE TOMATO CAFE Menu - Fishkill, NY

Laid-back cafe with a patio and a pastry counter offering an extensive Italian & American menu. Based on 653 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

THE TOMATO CAFE 12524

Address:
1123 Main St, Fishkill, NY 12524

Phone: (845) 896-7779

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday	11 AM–9 PM
Wednesday	11 AM–9 PM
Thursday	11 AM–9 PM
Friday	11 AM–9 PM
Saturday	11 AM–9 PM
Sunday	9 AM–3 PM
Monday	11 AM–9 PM

FOOD
Build Your Own Breakfast Sandwich	$4.00
The Supreme	$10.00
The Florentine	$8.00
The Canadian	$9.00
Pepper & Egg Sandwich	$7.00
Potato & Egg Sandwich	$7.00
Cafe Frittata	$13.00
Americana Breakfast	$12.00
Custom Smoothie	$7.00
Berry Smoothie	$7.00
Tropical Smoothie	$7.00
Tomato Soup A hearty, rustic Tomato soup, house specialty made fresh from our “secret” recipe. Top it off with crumbled bacon (add $1) or add a touch of cream (add $0.75)	$7.00
Garlic Bread Our house made garlic bread “cubes” served with our pomodoro sauce	$5.00
Fried Mozzarella Triangles of mozzarella breaded, fried and served with house-made pomodoro sauce	$9.75
Classic Bruschetta Toasted brick oven bread topped with the classic combination of tomato, basil, red onion and balsamic vinaigrette	$9.75
Bruschetta Of The Day Chef’s choice of fresh ingredients-sometimes sweet, sometimes savory	$14.00
Arancini Classic Italian Rice balls stuffed with mozzarella and served with our house-made pomodoro sauce	$13.00
Cafe Wings Your choice of Cafe Classic, BBQ, Teriyaki, Honey Sriracha or Sweet Chili served with carrots, celery and blue cheese dressing	$14.00
Cheese Steak Spring Rolls Our classic Fishkill cheesesteak in appetizer form- hand rolled shaved ribeye with american cheese, peppers & onions, served with choice of creamy chipotle or cream sriracha sauce	$14.00
Side House Salad	$4.75
Side Caesar Salad	$5.00
Soup #1- Chicken Tortilla W/Avocado	$7.00
Soup #2-Creamy Roasted Red Pepper W/Gouda	$7.00
Soup #3	$7.00
Bread For 2	$0.00
Bread For 6	$0.00
CAFE HOUSE SALAD A simple salad of mixed greens, cherry tomatoes, cucumber, red onion, carrot and our house dressing.	$9.75
CAESAR SALAD Romaine tossed with house-made traditional dressing, our croutons and parmesan	$10.00
INSALATA GRECA A mediterranean salad of cherry tomatoes, cucumber, green peppers, calamata olives and feta cheese, served over mixed greens with olive oil and fresh lemon juice.	$14.00
HARVEST SALAD Mixed greens topped with pecans, dried cranberries, goat cheese and our balsamic vinaigrette	$13.50
Buffalo Chicken Salad Our breaded chicken (feel free to substitute grilled) tossed in our cafe classic wing sauce served over romaine lettuce with tomato, red onion, applewood smoked bacon, cheddar and real ranch	$18.00
Cobb Salad Romaine hearts topped w/breaded chicken , bacon, avocado, tomato, hard boiled egg and our ranch dressing	$18.00
Cafe Tuna Salad Salad Nicoise, a fancy name for a classic salad- mixed greens, calamata olives, roasted potatoes, green beans, tomato, capers and hard boiled eggs topped with grilled tuna and our red wine vinaigrette	$18.00
Cafe Steak Salad Grilled marinated flank steak, sliced thin and served over mixed greens with grilled sweet onions, roasted red pepper, and our red wine vinaigrette. Add crumbled Bleu Cheese +3	$18.00
QUINOA BOWL warm quinoa with your choice of toppings and sauce	$13.00
Salad Special Please visit our website at tomatocafeny.com for details	$14.50
The Caprese	$15.00
Cafe Grilled Cheese A simple classic, served on Peasant bread, sourdough wheat or sourdough rye with your choice of cheese: American, Swiss, Provolone, Mozzarella, Cheddar or Gruyere Add grilled tomato for $1 add canadian bacon- $3 Add applewood bacon for $3.50	$10.00
Cafe BLT Another classic favorite, served on toasted Peasant bread, sourdough wheat or sourdough rye with tomato, romaine lettuce applewood smoked bacon and a side of mayo. “Club It” – – add grilled chicken or oven roasted turkey- $6 -add grilled tuna-$8 -add avocado-$3 Served on Flat Bread- $1.50	$12.00
Pastrami Reuben Our take on a traditional deli sandwich – pastrami on grilled sourdough rye with swiss and our house made 1000 island coleslaw	$14.00
Turkey Reuben Our take on a traditional deli sandwich – turkey on grilled sourdough rye with swiss and our house made 1000 island coleslaw	$13.00
Cafe Burger Premium 8oz Angus-served with lettuce, tomato, red onion and pickle	$14.00
Grilled Vegetable Wrap Eggplant, tomato, zucchini and squash with pesto remoulade, grilled and served on your choice of regular white wrap or wheat wrap	$13.00
Cafe Mozzarella Sandwich Thick slices of fresh mozzarella topped with tomato and arugula, drizzled with balsamic glaze, served on grilled flatbread wrap	$14.00
Cafe Parm-Chicken Breaded chicken cutlet with pomodoro sauce and melted mozzarella on a toasted hero	$14.00
Cafe Parm-Meatball Meatballs, house made form our special recipe of beef and pork, pomodoro and melted mozzarella on a toasted sub.	$13.00
Cafe Parm-Eggplant Breaded and fried, with pomodoro and melted mozzarella on a toasted sub	$12.00
Cafe Parm-Sausage Sweet italian sausage, pomodoro and melted mozzarella on a toasted sub…add peppers and/or onions if you’re feelin’ it	$13.00
Chicken-Bacon-Ranch Sandwich Fried chicken cutlet, with applewood smoked bacon, mozzarella cheese and our ranch dressing	$15.00
Fishkill Cheesesteak Shaved ribeye steak, grilled and topped with American cheese (of course you can substitute any cheese you please) served on a hero…ADD any or all: Grilled onions, peppers mushrooms	$15.00
Sandwich Special Please visit our website at tomatocafeny.com for details	$14.50
Chicken & Mushroom Wedge Marinated, grilled chicken breast topped with gruyere cheese, sauteed mushrooms and arugula served on a fresh baked hero	$15.00
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich	$14.00
Chicken Cafe Parm Dinner Breaded chicken cutlet topped with Cafe pomodoro sauce and mozzarella. Served with a side of linguini,	$15.00
Eggplant Cafe Parm Dinner Breaded and fried and topped with Cafe Pomodoro sauce and mozzarella, served with a side of linguine	$13.50
CHICKEN MARSALA Classic blend of pan-seared chicken and mushrooms in a herbed marsala sauce. Served with a side of linguini. For Mario’s fresh penne or rigatoni add $3	$15.00
CHICKEN PICCATA Not quite your “Nonna’s” Piccata. We take the classic, pan-seared chicken breast with lemon, butter and capers, and we add calamata olives, tomatoes and artichoke hearts. Served over linguini. For Mario’s fresh penne or rigatoni add $3.	$15.00
Grilled Chicken	$13.50
Flank Steak	$15.00
Tuna	$15.00
Salmon	$15.50
Shrimp	$15.50
Linguini Pomodoro Our simple, classic house made sauce: tomatoes, fresh basil, garlic and olive oil – over linguini and topped with parmesan. Switch to Mario’s fresh penne or rigatoni for $3. ADD meatballs or sausage for $4	$10.50
Pasta Primavera Linguini tossed with zucchini, yellow squash, red peppers, mushrooms and spinach with your choice of white wine lemon butter sauce or light red sauce. Switch to Mario’s fresh penne or rigatoni for $3	$13.50
Penne Ala Vodka A classic tomato cream sauce “fortified” with a shot of vodka	$14.50
Penne Pesto Fresh penne tossed in pesto cream sauce and topped with cherry tomatoes	$14.50
Baked Ziti Old school pasta dish- al dente penne tossed with our pomodoro sauce and herbed ricotta, topped with mozzarella cheese and baked til bubbly hot	$18.00
Macaroni & Cheese Mac & Cheese for grown ups – fresh penne with our blend of cheeses topped with toasted bread crumbs….ADD applewood bacon for $1	$14.50
Drunken’ Chicken Pan-seared chicken with sausage, onions, peppers, hot cherry peppers and white wine over rigatoni	$15.50
Chicken Sandoval A staff favorite – pan seared chicken topped with roasted red peppers and fresh mozzarella served over spinach and fresh rigatoni	$14.50
Entree Special #1-Butternut Squash Ravioli For full description, please see a tomatocafeny.com	$15.00
Entree #2- Pork Belly Rice Bowl For full description, please see at tomatocafeny.com	$22.00
Personal Traditional Pie	$13.75
Small Traditional Pie	$17.00
Large Traditional Pie	$18.50
Personal White Pie Mozzarella topped with blended ricotta	$16.00
Small White Pie Mozzarella topped with blended ricotta	$19.00
Large White Pie Mozzarella topped with blended ricotta	$20.50
Pizza Slice	$2.78
Special Slice	$3.75
Pizza Slice 1 Topping	$3.25
Pizza Roll	$6.00
Personal Margherita Our pomodoro sauce topped with fresh mozzarella and basil	$15.25
Personal Bruschetta Pizza Mozzarella topped with ore classic bruschetta- tomato, red onion, basil & balsamic glaze	$15.25
Personal BBQ Chicken Traditional pie topped with chicken tossed in BBQ sauce and finished with cheddar cheese and red onion	$17.75
Personal Chicken Parm Pizza Traditional pie topped with our pomodoro sauce, diced chicken cutlet, and fresh mozzarella	$17.25
Personal Pesto Pizza Mozzarella covering our house made pesto sauce and finished with diced tomatoes	$16.25
Personal Pizza Salsiccia Pomodoro sauce topped with sausage and grilled onions and finished with shaved parmesan	$17.25
Personal Pizza Alla Prosciutto Mozzarella topped with prosciutto, a touch of pomodoro sauce and finished with arugula	$18.25
Personal Garden Pizza Traditional pie topped with the traditional veggie toppings- mushrooms, green peppers, onions, tomatoes & black olives	$19.00
Personal Grilled Vegetable Pizza Mozzarella topped with grilled eggplant, tomato, zucchini, yellow squash and finished with a touch of garlic	$19.00
Personal Pizza Con Carne Traditional pie topped with pepperoni, sausage, meatball and bacon	$20.75
Personal Insalata Pizza Mozzarella topped with a salad of mixed greens, tomato & red onions tossed in our red wine vinaigrette	$16.25
Personal Hawaiian Pizza Traditional pie topped with Canadian bacon & pineapple	$17.25
Personal Calamata Pizza Mozzarella topped with calamata olives, artichoke hearts, tomatoes and garlic	$19.00
Personal Chicken-Bacon-Ranch Pizza Mozzarella topped with mushrooms, chicken and our house made marsala sauce	$19.50
Personal Chicken Marsala Pie	$18.25
Small Margherita Our pomodoro sauce topped with fresh mozzarella and basil	$18.50
Small Bruschetta Pizza Mozzarella topped with ore classic bruschetta- tomato, red onion, basil & balsamic glaze	$18.50
Small BBQ Chicken Traditional pie topped with chicken tossed in BBQ sauce and finished with cheddar cheese and red onion	$24.50
Small Chicken Parm Pizza Traditional pie topped with our pomodoro sauce, diced chicken cutlet, and fresh mozzarella	$23.50
Small Pesto Pizza Mozzarella covering our house made pesto sauce and finished with diced tomatoes	$22.50
Small Pizza Salsiccia Pomodoro sauce topped with sausage and grilled onions and finished with shaved parmesan	$23.50
Small Pizza Alla Prosciutto Mozzarella topped with prosciutto, a touch of pomodoro sauce and finished with arugula	$26.00
Small Garden Pizza Traditional pie topped with the traditional veggie toppings- mushrooms, green peppers, onions, tomatoes & black olives	$27.00
Small Grilled Vegetable Pizza Mozzarella topped with grilled eggplant, tomato, zucchini, yellow squash and finished with a touch of garlic	$27.00
Small Pizza Con Carne Traditional pie topped with pepperoni, sausage, meatball and bacon	$29.00
Small Insalata Pizza Mozzarella topped with a salad of mixed greens, tomato & red onions tossed in our red wine vinaigrette	$22.50
Small Hawaiian Pizza Traditional pie topped with Canadian bacon & pineapple	$24.00
Small Calamata Pizza Mozzarella topped with calamata olives, artichoke hearts, tomatoes and garlic	$27.00
Small Chicken-Bacon-Ranch Pizza Mozzarella topped with mushrooms, chicken and our house made marsala sauce	$27.00
Small Chicken Marsala Pizza	$26.00
Large Margherita Our pomodoro sauce topped with fresh mozzarella and basil	$20.00
Large Bruschetta Pizza Mozzarella topped with ore classic bruschetta- tomato, red onion, basil & balsamic glaze	$20.00
Large BBQChicken Traditional pie topped with chicken tossed in BBQ sauce and finished with cheddar cheese and red onion	$26.00
Large Chicken Parm Pizza Traditional pie topped with our pomodoro sauce, diced chicken cutlet, and fresh mozzarella	$25.00
Large Pesto Pizza Mozzarella covering our house made pesto sauce and finished with diced tomatoes	$24.00
Large Pizza Salsiccia Pomodoro sauce topped with sausage and grilled onions and finished with shaved parmesan	$25.00
Large Pizza Alla Prosciutto Mozzarella topped with prosciutto, a touch of pomodoro sauce and finished with arugula	$27.50
Large Garden Pizza Traditional pie topped with the traditional veggie toppings- mushrooms, green peppers, onions, tomatoes & black olives	$28.50
Large Grilled Vegetable Pizza Mozzarella topped with grilled eggplant, tomato, zucchini, yellow squash and finished with a touch of garlic	$28.50
Large Pizza Con Carne Traditional pie topped with pepperoni, sausage, meatball and bacon	$30.50
Large Insalata Pizza Mozzarella topped with a salad of mixed greens, tomato & red onions tossed in our red wine vinaigrette	$24.00
Large Hawaiian Pizza Traditional pie topped with Canadian bacon & pineapple	$25.50
Large Calamata Pizza Mozzarella topped with calamata olives, artichoke hearts, tomatoes and garlic	$28.50
Large Chicken-Bacon-Ranch Pizza Mozzarella topped with mushrooms, chicken and our house made marsala sauce	$28.50
Large Chicken Marsala	$28.50
Calzone	$12.00
Kids Chicken Fingers Fries	$8.00
Kids Pasta	$8.00
Kids Mac N Cheese	$8.00
SIDE OF FRIES	$2.50
SIDE SWEET POTATO FRIES	$4.00
SIDE SPINACH	$4.00
SIDE GREEN BEANS	$4.00
SIDE GR VEGGIES	$4.00
Side Of Broccoli	$4.00
SIDE GRILLED CHICKEN	$6.00
Side Of Breaded Chicken	$6.00
Side Of Meatballs	$4.00
Garlic Bread Our house made garlic bread “cubes” served with our pomodoro sauce	$5.00
Side Home Fries	$2.50
Side Of Bacon	$3.50
(5) Grilled Shrimp	$9.00
Side Of Avocado	$3.00
Side Of Fresh Mozzarella	$3.00
Side Of Rice	$2.50
Side Of Grilled Salmon	$9.00
Side Of Sauteed Mushrooms	$1.00
Side Flank Steak	$9.00
Waffle Fries	$4.00
Side Of Onion Rings	$4.00
Side Of Coleslaw	$2.50
N/A BEVERAGES
FOUNTAIN SODA (Dining In)	$3.00
LG FOUNTAIN TO-GO	$2.50
SM FOUNTAIN TO-GO	$2.00
BOYLAN SODA	$4.00
20 OZ. BOTTLED SODA	$2.50
2L SODA	$4.50
Pure Leaf BOTTLE ICED TEA`	$3.00
BOTTLE WATER	$2.00
500 Ml Pellegrino	$4.00
MILK	$3.50
Chocolate Milk	$3.50
COFFEE	$2.75
ICED COFFEE	$3.00
LIPTON TEA	$2.75
HARNEY & SONS TEA	$3.50
ESPRESSO	$3.50
CAPPUCCINO	$5.00
Decaf Cappucino	$5.00
LATTE	$5.00
Iced Latte	$6.00
HOT CHOCOLATE	$3.00
SM TO-GO COFFEE	$2.50
LG TO-GO COFFEE	$3.00
DESSERTS
CHOCOLATE LAVA CAKE	$8.00
ITALIAN LEMON CAKE	$9.00
Bread Pudding	$9.00
TIRAMISU	$8.00
CHEESECAKE	$9.00
Carrot Cake	$9.00
JANE’S ICE CREAM	$4.00
Kids Ice Cream	$2.00
FRIED DOUGH	$8.00
Root Beer Float	$5.00
Chocolate Chip Cookie	$1.00
Milkshake	$6.00

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Big Joe

Great family spot with friendly service and good food. Traditional Pizzeria with a twist. They have breakfast sandwiches all day (will have to give them a try). You’ve got your chicken parmesan, but also a Reubens Sandwich. Nice variations on pizza types and sizes. Dessert menu had plenty to choose from. We tried Jane’s local ice cream and the fried dough (not a zeppole or funnel cake, but somewhere in between). Powdered sugar or cinnamon sugar. The fried dough was light, airy and not greasy. It’s good and deserves a better name than fried dough. How about fritto e dolce…it means fried and sweet! Not a complaint, because the entrance and outside seating are cool, but inside needs a little TLC.Prices were good. Highly recommend.

… more

Betsy Van Die

I had a delicious hamburger with an equally exceptional side garden salad – the house dressing was superb. The burger was so huge that I brought half back to my friend’s house. The service was very good until our waiter made us wait 20 minutes to pay after giving us the bill. In any case, the next time I visit my friend in Beacon, I wouldn’t hesitate to dine here again.

… more

Ninoska Ramos Miguel

This is a restaurant you must visit, food is delicious the coffee is the BEST and the little cookie they give you with it yummyy servers are super friendly, dog friendly as well.

… more

Anne Wolfe

The pizza dough was nice, the sauce was great.

… more

Frank PolievkaJr

Just passing through, I decided to give this place a try! SO GLAD I did! The atmosphere is very small town friendly and has that welcoming feeling. The salad was very fresh and had a really earthy flavor, like just picked from the garden, and a good size portion. For dinner I went with the Chicken Parm / half portion, excellent crust on the chicken and the sauce was very fresh and robust! The lava cake dessert À la mode was amazing but too much for one person. Sitting at the front counter over looking Main Street was an enjoyable experience for dinner! I highly recommend and will return to try another meal in the future.

… more

Kristian Singh-Nergård

Good food, reasonable prices and friendly staff. The eggs benedict were perfect and the fries were excellent. The Cafe Parms was delicious and I’ll highly recommend it. The waitress messed up our order and brought us regular fries instead of sweet potato fries. I overheard someone else who’s order had been messed up as well. A little more attentiveness and I would have rated this place 5 stars.

… more

Ed Gatzke

Great little place. All our food was solid. Small selection of regional craft beers. A little spendy. Good service. Great little find. Try them out!

… more

Nishant Shah

It’s a nice restaurant conveniently located and many options for vegetarians. We ordered bruschetta, margarita pizza and penne pizza and it was amazing. We asked then to bake well and it was perfectly crispy. One thing I would like to add is they don’t serve pasta on Sunday and we were disappointed first but pizza and bruschetta were so yummy we forgot about that the moment we started eating our food. Ambience was also very nice and they have sitting area outside as well.

… more

Linc Meade

Awesome pizza and sandwiches. Decent beer selection, very reasonable prices. I was impressed and will definitely be back again. Staff was great also.

… more

Janelle Marina Mendez

Parking: Its a little difficult during dinner to find parking.

… more

… View more

Hours

Menu

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

THE TOMATO CAFE Menu – Fishkill, NY

Hours

Menu

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Related:

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions