Based on 29 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price
Address:
636 9th St, Cimarron, NM 87714
Phone: (575) 376-2228
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Sara Burns
We stopped here for a quick lunch while traveling, and it far exceeded our expectations. I visited the website and read the reviews, and wasn’t quite sure what to expect from “casual fine-dining,” but truly – there is no better explanation. The atmosphere is laid back and casual with a comfortable patio and nice views, but the food is 5-star fine dining. The menu changes so you won’t know what to expect until you arrive unless you call ahead; however, there were enough choices to please various palates but not so many as to overwhelm. The price included bread, choice of coffee, tea, or water, entree, and dessert. Each part of the meal was better than the last. We were served croissants and carrot cake muffins after being seated, and we could have filled up on that alone. For entrees, we had the panini (turkey, Swiss, baked cinnamon apples), green chili stew, and the Benedict. Everything was cooked perfectly and full of flavor. The star of the show was definitely the dessert. I don’t recall what it was called, but it was a pastry with a cream cheese filling and a blueberry compote. It was phenomenal. Food aside, the part of the meal that pleased me most was the owners. They were welcoming, accommodating, and gracious. It felt like we were enjoying a meal at the house of an old friend. We had 4 tired and cranky children ages 4 and under, and the owner engaged them, put their food on individual plates without us even asking, and was more than gracious about our children being children. Stop here. You won’t regret it.
… more
Stephanie Pollard
We stopped here for Sunday brunch on our road trip to Custer SD after seeing the great reviews on google. This place deserves 10/5 stars!! The food was phenomenal, the owners and service was phenomenal, couldn’t have asked for a better experience! If you’re looking for a place to eat while traveling through Cimarron, THIS IS THE PLACE to go!! Check or cash only 🙂
… more
Jess Friedman
Of all the restaurants I’ve eaten at, this is my favorite. The food is incredibly good, the service is wonderful, and the atmosphere is welcoming and relaxing. Their reuben sandwich raised the bar for me, and I’ve yet to find one to top it. I also really love the cucumber salad and their soups are delicious.
… more
Loverly_ Daizy
We go here every couple weeks and everytime we go we always have the absolute best service and experience! The sunday brunch Reuben special is fantastic!!! Roger the owner is always so friendly and welcoming, highly recommended this restaurant! Heads up they only take cash.
… more
Cindy Jeide
I have always loved the porch, as much for the food as wonderful owner and staff. Sharon and Rodger are friendly and helpful. Highly recommend you stop in and try their food which is made with love and care and you can tell.
… more
Nick Hutchinson
Quaint little spot. Menu is limited. Would not be an issue if quality made up for it, but… Vendor does not accept credit card payment, so be prepared with cash.
… more
Tom Giugni
There is always a limited menu, beef or pork, chicken or fish and vegetarian. Sharon tried new recipes most weeks. They are always good and moderately priced.
… more
Kevin Andrew
We came here after our Philmont trek with our scout group and the food was delicious and service was friendly and prompt. Definitely recommend.
… more
Christian Johnson
A very inviting place for Sunday brunch. Very friendly and small townish. Food selection was good and food was great. A great place in Cimarron.
… more
Len Furia
food is good, service is splendid. go there every summer for lunch during time off from Philmont scout Ranch
… more
… View more