Based on 180 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
940 Old Trail Rd, Goldsboro, PA 17319
Phone: (717) 938-2217
Website: https://thepizzashopofetters.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
silverspoon819
This pizza shop is amazing. The owner Mike was kind enough to let me step into the kitchen and take a picture of the food on the grill. What an awesome guy he is. Super fun to talk to. Nice, clean, wide open kitchen. No dining area so if you come in, plan to take your food to go. Worth every penny. His motto is “if you’re paying $12 for a sub you’re going to get $12 worth of sub.” And dang, was it worth it. I will defiantly become a regular. Look on his fB for specials too.
… more
Sam W
We ordered delivery, garlic knots and a cheese and sausage pizza.
… more
Alina Abbas
TL;DR: great service, great food!
… more
Stacy Evans
Go to USA& I and have diarrhea at two am in the morning. Go to Patriot Pizza and have to go home and cook the pizza in the oven because the dough is raw. Go to Brother’s pizza and choke on crust that is way to thick. Go here and have one of the best pizzas you have ever had. Love this place and love the group running it.
… more
Douglas DeLuca
Would give 10 stars if I could!!! Stumbled on this gem while traveling. The owner Mike might be the nicest pizza shop owner I’ve ever met. I ordered an Italian sub and a Pepperoni pizza and they were both incredible. Being from Buffalo we take our pizza very seriously, and Mike is putting out absolutely top notch, cheesy, crusty, delicious pizza. I left wishing I ordered an extra sub for later, an very full 🙂
… more
ffczifro
Pizzas are awesome and cooked how you like them (well done for me). Only complaint is the sauce, sometimes it’s been bland and watery, but overall it’s been only a couple of times. Don’t know if they’re selling the huge pizzas they used to, heard they stopped making them.
… more
Harrison Boyer
Pizza was fantastic. Easily would recommend. Staff is also super friendly. Will definitely order again and would easily recommend to anyone!
… more
Maximiliana Senkbeil
Placed Order. Friendly staff gave me my total while on the phone with them. Charged exactly as their published prices showed. Received my order within the hour by the owner, who was super friendly. They will be my go-to delivery restaurant for now on. I will not stray again. Go and support them.
… more
Jenn Murphy
We have just started ordering from my place of employment!! Mike is great and always takes care of us. Quality of food is great and the price is right as well. If your looking for a pizza shop try them out!!
… more
Natasha Siple
NOW THERE IS AN ICE CREAM TRUCK!! If you add SpongeBob with gumball eyes, you’ll literally have my entire bank account. I order pizza here at least once a week and recently discovered the pickle pizza is good with pineapples so make that twice a week, it’s a problem. I will also be using Pizza Shop of Etters to cater my 4 demons bday party. The pizza can be an orgasm in your mouth cuz they use the best cheese EVER. Even the provolone is top notch.. if you’re looking for “that pizza place”, this is it. Tell your friends.
… more
… View more