Best of the Region Winner 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021 & 2022! Hand-tossed authentic, Italian pizza using our 40-year-old family recipes. We guarantee our daily-mixed dough and high quality ingredients will provide you with a superior pizza experience. This isn’t your typical pizza shop, it is THE Pizza Shop!
Based on 295 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
3918 Main St, Warrensburg, NY 12885
Phone: (518) 623-3070
Website: http://www.thepizzashopwarrensburg.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Sarah Easter
This pizza was delicious! The garlic knots were amazing (like buy a few orders). My chicken wings were a bit of a disappointment for me but I like them super crispy and they were a little soggy for my taste. The prices are great for the generous slices you get. I see why it is voted best in the region.
… more
Double Decker Fam
We asked a few locals where the best pizza in the area was and they said “it’s not just the best pizza in the area, it’s the best pizza in the world.” So, we brought the whole family here to give it a try. The locals did not steer us wrong.
… more
Hawaiiantrixie
Very good pizza. New york thin crust. Bone in chicken wings were crispy and flavorful. And we actually received the extra blue cheese we requested. We order 3 pizzas and a Ceasar salad, meatball platter, 2 kinds of bone in wings. Only thing for us. Chicken Ceasar salad was a little dry with the Ceasar dressing. Perfect foldable slices!
… more
John
I thought the wings were very good! We ordered them naked and a variety of dipping sauces. The pizza was just good for me, but that was my opinion. The dining room was very busy and it had good reviews. I’d visit again for sure.
… more
Kim Kelley
We have found our new pizza place!! The pizza is QUALITY & the service was super fast and friendly. Prices are just right too! We walked in tonight and ordered a large pie to go- they had it ready in no time. The atmosphere is clean and the artwork is impressive. Can’t wait to try other menu items.
… more
John M. Palladino
The owner was not there when we ordered. We waited a long time for our pie. We asked the status and the server checked. We saw them pull the pie from a box snd bring it to us. It was cold. Had them reheat it. Quality reduced as it had to be reheated. The pie was not very tasty. As we were eating the pie, the owner returned, noticed he went to every station an made changes to what the employees were doing. Msybe we should give this place another chance when the owner is there!
… more
JC
I don’t understand how this pizza place has won awards or even has good reviews.
… more
Kate Demers
I ordered a small pepperoni, mushroom and onion…a little well done, was cooked perfect. The pizza was delivered hot and exactly what I expected..
… more
louis Charles
Only had the Margarita. Crust and sauce are good, not enough cheese. Cheese was sliced and not broken apart, difficult to get true flavors. Overall could have used a few drops of a good oil. Next time I will try regular pie!!
… more
Bryn Dunham
Really Good pizza and good garlic knots (just too small!) We all enjoyed. Just a little pizza joint not fancy at all.
… more
… View more