The Old Stone Tavern Menu – Rochester, NY

Type : Restaurant

Location : Rochester, NY

Based on 639 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery

The Old Stone Tavern 14620

Address:
758 South Ave, Rochester, NY 14620

Phone: (585) 448-1148

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday 11:30 AM–10 PM
Wednesday 11:30 AM–10 PM
Thursday 11:30 AM–10 PM
Friday 11:30 AM–11:30 PM
Saturday 11:30 AM–11:30 PM
Sunday 11 AM–10 PM
Monday 11:30 AM–10 PM

Menu

Salads
Grilled Wedge Salad
Lightly grilled heart of romaine drizzled in bleu cheese dressing, topped with thick cherry wood smoked bacon. Choose a salad dressing: Balsamic Vinaigrette, Bleu Cheese Dressing, Ranch Dressing
$10.00
Buffalo Salad
Romaine salad with a grilled or fried chicken breast tossed in your choice of wing sauce. Served with choice of homemade dressing. Choose a style: Grilled Chicken Breast, Fried Chicken Breast. Choose a sauce: Mild Buffalo Sauce, Hot Buffalo Sauce, Instantly Buffalo Sauce, Cracked Pepper Garlic Parm Sauce, Sriracha BBQ Sauce, Korean BBQ Sauce, Stone Sweet Sauce, Spicy Maple Sauce, Honey Mustard Sauce, Jamaican Jerk Sauce. Choose a salad dressing: Balsamic Vinaigrette, Bleu Cheese Dressing, Ranch Dressing
$12.00
Wings
10 Traditional Wings
Hand-tossed with choice of any of our homemade sauces. Choose a sauce: Mild Buffalo Sauce, Hot Buffalo Sauce, Instantly Buffalo Sauce, Cracked Pepper Garlic Parm Sauce, Sriracha BBQ Sauce, Korean BBQ Sauce, Stone Sweet Sauce, Spicy Maple Sauce, Honey Mustard Sauce, Jamaican Jerk Sauce
$12.50
Wing Flight
Twelve (12) wings, naked. Includes choice of 3 sauces. Choose 3 sauces: Mild Buffalo Sauce, Hot Buffalo Sauce, Insanity Buffalo Sauce, Cracked Pepper Garlic Parm Sauce, Sriracha BBQ Sauce, Honey Wasabi Sauce, Korean BBQ Sauce, Stone Sweet Sauce, Spicy Maple Sauce, Honey Mustard Sauce, Jamaican Jerk Sauce
$16.00
Between the Buns
The Stone Steak Burger
Combining short rib, brisket and chuck in one magical burger with choice of cheese, fillers and bun. Served with choice of side. Choose a meat preparation: Rare, Medium Rare, Medium, Medium Well, Well Done. Choose a cheese: American Cheese, Sharp Cheddar Cheese, Swiss Cheese, Provolone Cheese, No Cheese. Choose a bun: Traditional Bun, Pretzel Bun, Gluten Free Bun, No Bun. Would you like to add fillers?: Ketchup, Mustard, Relish, Regular Pickles, Spicy Pickles, Meat Sauce(+ $0.50), Chili(+ $0.50), Mac and Cheese(+ $0.50), Fried Egg(+ $1.00), Thick Cut Bacon(+ $1.50). Choose a side: Fries, Sweet Potato Wedges, Tots, Onion rings, Mac and Cheese, Coleslaw, Side Salad with Balsamic Vinaigrette, Side Salad with Blue Cheese Dressing, Side Salad with Ranch Dressing
$13.50
Fried Chicken Sandwich
Louisiana style fried chicken finished with any of our home made sauces, fillers and bun. Served with choice of side. Choose a bun: Traditional Bun, Pretzel Bun, Gluten Free Bun, No Bun. Choose a sauce: Mild Buffalo Sauce, Hot Buffalo Sauce, Instantly Buffalo Sauce, Cracked Pepper Garlic Parm Sauce, Sriracha BBQ Sauce, Korean BBQ Sauce, Stone Sweet Sauce, Spicy Maple Sauce, Honey Mustard Sauce, Jamaican Jerk Sauce. Choose a cheese: American Cheese, Sharp Cheddar Cheese, Swiss Cheese, Provolone Cheese, No Cheese. Would you like to add fillers?: Ketchup, Mustard, Relish, Regular Pickles, Spicy Pickles, Meat Sauce(+ $0.50), Chili(+ $0.50), Mac and Cheese(+ $0.50), Fried Egg(+ $1.00), Thick Cut Bacon(+ $1.50). Choose a side: Fries, Sweet Potato Wedges, Tots, Onion rings, Mac and Cheese, Coleslaw, Side Salad with Balsamic Vinaigrette, Side Salad with Blue Cheese Dressing, Side Salad with Ranch Dressing
$12.50
Dogs
The Stone Dog
Grilled and cut on the spiral to give choice of toppings a place to settle. Served on choice of bun. Choose a bun: Traditional Bun, Pretzel Bun, Gluten Free Bun, No Bun. Would you like toppings?: Ketchup, Mustard, Relish, Onions, Regular Pickles, Spicy Pickles, Meat Sauce(+ $0.50), Chili(+ $0.50), Mac and Cheese(+ $0.50), Shredded Cheddar Cheese(+ $0.50), Sauerkraut(+ $0.50), Bacon(+ $0.50)
$5.00
The Veggie Dog
A big carrot poached in our special marinade, grilled then finished with choice of toppings. Choose a bun: Traditional Bun, Pretzel Bun, Gluten Free Bun, No Bun. Would you like toppings?: Ketchup, Mustard, Relish, Onions, Regular Pickles, Spicy Pickles, Meat Sauce(+ $0.50), Chili(+ $0.50), Mac and Cheese(+ $0.50), Shredded Cheddar Cheese(+ $0.50), Sauerkraut(+ $0.50), Bacon(+ $0.50)
$5.50
Plates
One-Dog Plate
One dog (red or white) on top of mac salad and tots, topped with meat sauce, chopped onion and mustard.One-Dog Choice: Red Hot, White Hot,
$10.50
Two-Dog Plate
Two dogs (red, white, or one of each) on top of mac salad and tots, topped with mustard, onion, and meat sauce.Two Dog Choice: Two Red, Two White, One Red, One White
$12.00

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Matthew Sansone
Received a recommendation about the food from a co-worker and they were not wrong. The creativity of the combinations and the taste was very well executed. We were having trouble deciding what to have because multiple items sounded so good. And we were distracted (in a good way) by the Sunday brunch page of the menu. Had the General Tso chicken sandwich with onion rings and the crab Rangoon pizza – so good. Not just an addition of 1 thing and call it a new name, but thought out from the beginning. And there are TVs with sports scores and really yummy looking pictures of their food.

… more

Steve Cortese
Not much to look at from the street, but don’t let that fool you. Go in and try it. It’s not old and not stone, if you were expecting that. Don’t worry though it’s worth the stop.

… more

Elyse R
I was helping my cousin move some stuff up to their new apartment in Rochester, and we stopped here for a meal afterwards. There were several accommodations needed for our party, and we had stopped at 3 other restaurants before finding this place. They were able to accommodate the food allergies in our group, along with iptions for the children in our party. Personally, I ordered their Animal Style Smash Burger. When I reached the table it outshined its western counterpart, the In-and-Out Animal style burgers, and exceeded my expectations. They even made my kid a custom 10″ Buffalo Chicken pizza.

… more

Savannah
The onion rings are amazing! We went on a Sunday night, which was slightly busy. They were understaffed for the night, but Todd and the rest of the team were fantastic!! I ordered the Stone Steak Burger with a side of onion rings. Cannot wait to come back!

… more

S N
I love this place & have been coming here for years – always putting out great food. Called ahead for two orders of boneless wings & came with no sauce, no dry rub, nothing after we specified our choices over the phone. Disappointing the lack of attention to detail & rushing through orders just because the restaurant is busy. Better to have your customers wait an extra 10min for their order instead of giving them less than what they paid for.

… more

Nick Mastro
Great environment in a cozy little room. Don’t expect any privacy as the main room is pretty tight. Definitely do expect to get some delicious food as most of their menu was created unique to their bar. Beer selection was average, but the food is definitely the star of the show here.

… more

Theresa Hanna
The food selection was varied and provided extensive choices. Each entree our group members ordered was exceptional in taste and presentation. The service was wonderful and the waitress was helpful as well as personable. We plan to try the brunch next time we get together.

… more

Lucy Seal
Came in a few weeks ago before a hockey game for a quick bite and a drink and was pretty disappointed. Not sure if we just came on a bad day or what – it was a Friday night but the place was relatively empty. There were multiple workers there but it seemed only one woman was doing most of the work. There was no wait, but it took about 5 minutes to be greeted/seated and another 5 to be approached for our drink orders – when my drink finally arrived it was completely flat. It took a while to get her attention to get a new drink, but she apologized and told me that the coke machine is broken. Understandable, but it’s pretty easy to tell if a drink is bubbly or not. I ordered the pizza slice and my partner ordered a burger. Both were about the same quality and price as stadium food – ultimately just felt like a waste of time as that’s where we were going anyway. I’d be willing to go back and see if it was just an off day, but I was not impressed by my first experience here.

… more

C. Hasenauer
Very friendly staff, food was delicious. Price was about right. We came in for some Bar style food and got way more than that. The chicken fingers seem homemade and fried in peanut oil (if they’re not you fooled me!) Also had Mozz stick which were EXCELLENT We will return for another early dinner again

… more

Kirk Leckinger
Great service, atmosphere and food. Fresh, made to order by the owner and server was very friendly. Will be going back. Got to support the local businesses and this one was very good.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions