Casual waterfront eatery & bar offering an island-inspired menu & cocktails amid tropical decor. Based on 593 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
227 Bayview Ave, Put-In-Bay, OH 43456
Phone: (419) 285-5397
Website: http://thekeyspib.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Lynn Fox
We came to the keys because of their black bean burger, and came back the next day because it’s the only meatless burger in town. It was really good!! The fries were also fantastic. My partner got the tacos one day and got the blackened chicken grilled cheese. We also tried some drinks which included reusable cups. Everything was amazing and that’s why we keep going back! Staff have also been very kind about checking ingredients as necessary to make sure things are vegan for me. Id love it if they got more vegan options as they end up attracting vegetarians and vegans with their black bean burger, but I’m already so happy with them for being my only food option on the island.
… more
Eva Munch
Loved it. Live music, great atmosphere and friendly staff. Seating outside or inside. This place is located near the Jet Express ferry ⛴️. We came here while waiting for our ferry to arrive. A great place to pop in and enjoy food and drinks.
… more
Maria Klisanin-Klaum
Amazing food and atmosphere. Fast service. We were at a table right by the water. Felt like we were in Florida! Higher end in price range. Also have a kids menu.
… more
Ashleigh Vasi
The food was good. My daughter did not like the seasoned/spicy fries. The musician was great. Love the view of the water. Had the perch sandwich and it was delicious.
… more
Sonia Turtaro
Excellent live performance and great atmosphere. Did not eat there, so I can’t say if it is good or not . Drinks were good.
… more
Edward Farnsworth
I went twice, two years apart. The atmosphere is a really great on-the-lake experience. They had live musicians playing during lunch, which was a definite plus. I got the daily special-a Carribean-jerk grilled cheese (I think it was $16. Pic included) – It was fairly bland. I also tasted some of the breaded perch and thought that was perfect. They have a pretty big menu, so I feel comfortable saying it’s a lot of typical freezer-to-fryer fare. Servers were very friendly and helpful, but both times I have been there, it took a painfully long time. Price was about what I would expect for the atmosphere, but nothing else about the experience was all that stellar.
… more
Scott Evans
The fish sandwich was fantastic and huge, but also $30 which I probably wouldn’t have ordered if the price was posted instead of “seasonal prices” but seriously probably the best fish sandwich I’ve ever had and the onion rings were also amazing! Service was friendly and attentive. Live music was also good. Overall a good spot but pricey for regular food. We were in for over $60 for a fish sandwich, 2 tacos, and 2 drinks.
… more
Jason
Nice location and great patio to sit on. Service was good. Menu stinks: 2 canned light beer, 1 small frozen slush drink, two fish sandwiches and a small cup of corn dip with tortilla chips=$102 (before tip) . Ugh
… more
Rohini Yalamanchilli
Super menu. Food is delicious. For vegetarian, black bean burger with a side of rice and beans, sweet potato fries is great. Their chicken soup is good too. Great service. Outdoor seating is pleasant except for the fact that could see few water snakes. Nice ambience. Neat restrooms.
… more
Karen Thomas
Great place love the atmosphere, great service the waitresses are super friendly
… more
… View more