Based on 199 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
220 Allen St, Buffalo, NY 14201
Phone: (716) 864-4459
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 12 PM–12 AM |
| Wednesday | 12 PM–12 AM |
| Thursday | 12 PM–12 AM |
| Friday | 12 PM–3 AM |
| Saturday | 12 PM–3 AM |
| Sunday | 12 PM–12 AM |
| Monday | Closed |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
steve c
My first visit to the hoagie stop ..very tasty. The good, it’s awesome that we have a true Philly cheesesteak place in buffalo. Jim’s and all the rest of them are kind of a poor imitation. They mix the cheese into the meat/onions/peppers instead of just slapping it on top, the way God intended. The bad. I’m not sure what is in the greater state of disrepair, the hoagie stop, or Allen Street. The ugly, unfortunately because of the construction, there’s no place to sit down. And the food simply doesn’t travel well. soggy fries and hoagie was a hot mess after the 15 minute ride home. But it tasted very good. Hoagie is 5/8 sub size
… more
Noah Safraniec
The first thing I said when we got our bag was “this is heavy” we stopped in and loved the options! The west side special sounded good, but we decided to take advantage of an UberEats deal that they informed us of. It was 2 for 1 steak hoagies. I don’t use UberEats but def wanted to take advantage of a deal bc it was pretty expensive for a sandwich IMO. I downloaded the app, but for some reason I couldn’t locate the restaurant! (This was probs a tech issue on my end) The gentleman running the register honored the deal anyway which was super nice! We also got fries and they were some of the best we’ve ever had!! The fries are a must have! The hoagies were made w/ love and generous in size. This is the type of food that will put you in a trance while you eat… in a good way!! Don’t expect to do much physical activity after They don’t have seating inside and no bathroom so it’s take-out only
… more
Adrianna Zullich
Previously walked right by here when looking for a hoagie. No more. This hoagie pretzel was delicious and stuffed 3 people. I look forward to coming back.
… more
CL Davidson
I am very disappointed with my food. I have ordered from you with no issues… but today not acceptable. … I got cold burnt fries and did not receive my Coke Zero or Orange Fanta…the steak was very good…but for the amount of money I paid I should have received all my order and better fries..
… more
Jaye Thompson
I wanted a steak hoagie while visiting Buffalo and my cousin recommended The Hoagie Shop. Best hoagie I’ve had in years! The steak was chopped very very dine. The cheese was smooth and the floor was wonderful. The amount of ingredients was plentiful. I purchased one for my father and he was so excited that he ate the whole thing in one sitting. This is not an eat in location and is not wheelchair accessible.
… more
Michelle Dombrowski
Was my first time here today and all I can say is WOW. The food is absolutely delicious you will not be disappointed. The subs are packed with meat and toppings, this is the best steak sub in Buffalo ! Will definitely be going again
… more
Leesha Richards
Overall nice space, enjoyed the murals. The lady at the front counter moved fast and was efficient. The food portion was large and justified the high prices. Drink options are great. The fries were harder/dry but looked fresh cut. I thought the American cheese ruined the flavors in the hoagie. I’m not American so forget that is most times the standard cheese. It gave it a bland bitter taste. If I return I’d ask for a different cheese. Otherwise I would recommend.
… more
Loretta Rogers
My Husband drove us to Buffalo from NYC on a Thursday…we got into Buffalo at 10:40 PM. We wanted something to eat, but the places we knew about closed at 10:30 PM. We sent a text to our Fam and they told us about The Hoagie Stop. The Steak n Cheese in a Pita is FIRE and the fresh cut fries are seasoned so well! This is the first take out food that I didn’t have to add ANYTHING to…no salt, no ketchup no NOTHING. You just eat and Enjoy! Definitely going back to The Hoagie Stop to bring a couple of those Steak n Cheese Pitas back to NYC! And the young man who took our order was very courteous…Nothing like Great Food and Great Service!
… more
Owen Szantor
Truly in awe of the sandwich I got last night. I knew it was going to be amazing because you can see the chefs make it, and these are not just ordinary fry cooks. These are ARTISTS. You can watch them move with passion and precision, cooking up the densest, tastiest hoagies there are. I wasn’t even drunk and it was a life experience. You might be looking at the menu and say hmmm 14 dollars for a hoagie?? DO IT. I WOULDVE PAID 30.
… more
Kelly R
The moment I walked in I was greeted. I Advised It was the first time I was there . I was recommend a steak and I believe sausage combo minced and diced together into a pita bread with cheese and onions . The pita bread was so soft, and the meat very fresh and hot. It came with fries, also crispy and fully cooked and Sauce with a drink. Expect to be in a food induced coma for at least 3 hours haha. The food was excellent in general. Decor was very nice. The only thing I could recommend is AC as I can see it getting hot in there in the summer.
… more
… View more