Based on 194 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
126 S Montezuma St, Prescott, AZ 86303
Phone: (928) 277-0726
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Friday | 11 AM–2 AM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–2 AM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–7 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–7 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–7 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–7 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jess in Prescott
Went in today and ordered. When I looked at the receipt, all of the prices were 20-40%higher than what was on the board (the price of by the slice pizza that was written on the dry erase board was also higher). I asked the woman who took our order and she said they have a new board ordered and have raised the prices. That was not mentioned to us when taking out order and it wasn’t added to the board temporarily, even though they had painter’s tape all over it cover items they no longer offered. We had been overcharged more than $8 for 2 people. Fine, I moved on. It wasn’t worth the argument at the moment. It was hot in there and I was hungry. We got our food and it wasn’t worth the original price. My pizza was undercooked, the sauce had been watered down (like the soap in the bathroom), and just kind of flavorless. The fried zucchini was hot, but soggy. I had seen this place for years and had always meant to go in, we finally do, and it couldn’t be more disappointing.
… more
Sara abadallah
We can in and wanted to order things for me my friends and my kids while looking at the menu the gelled saying all they have left was the left over pizza from the day. They were rude and when we asked questions they were careless not wanting to even give us a minute of there time even after we bought pizza they were rude ! We threw away the pizza we bought and went to the bistro at the corner and so glad we dude don’t come here unless you want to be treated like trash!
… more
Joy Morrison
AA++ True New York thin crust pizza right here in Prescott! We are from Brooklyn and we know what real New York Pizza is. The perfect ratio of sauce & cheese and the crust is amazing! The only place to go if you want the best!
… more
Robbie Sirrine
Great pizza. Very NYC style. The wait was long, primarily because the guy forgot we had ordered pizzas and never called them out once they were ready. They were busy, sure, but no excuse. Oh, and as the sign says, it’s fully of grumpy people.
… more
M Rey
Terrible service when we asked a question we completely got ignored. We ended up buying a pizza and throwing it away because of the terrible service. The bathrooms were clean but the staff in the kitchen was disrespectful. Never going there again.
… more
Dan Nowlan
Oh my god, so good. Get the Grumpy Sicilian. Just a slice. No sauce needed – just fired crust, melted ricotta, and a few other ingredients is all that’s needed. Yum.
… more
Rose Mullins
Went in an hour before closing. Could not order what we wanted because they were closing soon ( fried zucchini or certain pizza’s ). The young man working the counter was rubbing and playing with is greasy hair while handling food. He was also vaping while all customers could see. So disgusted and unprofessional!
… more
Katrina Sandy-Colon
Love love LOVE this pizza!!!! Hands down best pizza in town! If you want a quick slice or delicious lunch stop here! Everything looks and smells soooo good! Really want to try the garlic knots next time. When you see a group of locals stopping in to eat when they get off work you know it’s good!!
… more
Viviana Artiga
Most amazing pizza!!!!!!!!!!!
… more
Justin Spinks
Authentic AF – Hands down the best pizza in Prescott!!! The guy who owns the place and makes the pizza is Italian so you know it’s the real deal. This guy doesn’t mess around when it comes to pizza – The fresh toppings and the handmade dough are the perfect combination. Last time I had pizza this good was in New York.
… more
… View more