Based on 294 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
Address:
16 S Cleveland Ave, Mogadore, OH 44260
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Robert Willoughby
This may be the best pizza I have ever had. The baked ricotta was most excellent as well. Leah was a great, kind, helpful, and attentive server. This place is well worth the price and the service is excellent.
… more
Josh S
Classic thin crust is the only pizza they serve. Personally I am a fan of thin crust so this doesn’t bother me. Flavor of pizza is robust with just enough hints of Italian seasons (close to pizza fire but not quite there). Atmosphere is warm and inviting with the kitchen visible on the first floor. Prices are on the high side for Mogadore buy we enjoyed it.
… more
Jennifer Schwidde
Amazing food. Our table enjoyed [and shared] the crab cakes, baked ricotta, chicken Alfredo, bruchetta salad with salmon, and lobster mac and cheese. Oh my. Each dish was delicious.
… more
Mike Griffith
Wish I had a picture of my surf and turf before I scarfed it down! Incredible menu and fantastic execution with a home town feel. Pizza is top notch.
… more
Robin Merideth
Booked a Plant Nite through Groupon for my mom’s birthday. Plant Nite is a sister company to Paint Nite. Here you get to plant succulents in a terrarium. The Clay Oven is closed on Mondays, so they opened for this special event. We had a blast. Thee food was great and God bless our servers. They were great the entire evening. I can’t wait to go back to have pizza with my family.
… more
Amanda Engelhart
Excellent atmosphere, drink selection, and food. Food is fresh and delicious. Prices reasonable.
… more
Courtney Eiland
The food was amazing. We held our work Christmas Party here and I ordered the Crab stuffed Salmon and it was the best I’ve ever had, even enjoyed the side dishes. Carrie our bartender made sure we had everything we needed as far as beverages. Joe and Tiffany were great as well. I would definitely recommend this establishment to everyone. I plan on returning soon.
… more
E. Dillene Vanaman
I spoke to Joe about possibly bringing a wedding rehearsal group in for dinner.
… more
Kelly Pait
Absolutely amazingly fresh food with fabulous service! We had a fairly large table including children. We ordered a variety of foods including the most delicious pizza I’ve ever tried, lasagna and lobster mac and cheese. Everything was steaming hot, fresh and so so good. I recommend this restaurant for a great date night, a girl’s day lunch or family dinner. The restaurant itself is absolutely gorgeous with a very rich, local history of the interior. The staff was all super friendly! Cannot wait to go back and visit again!
… more
Paul S
I really like this place, despite okay service. The waitress was nice, but kind of inattentive.
… more
… View more