The Classic New York Pizza Joint has earned a reputation as one of the area’s most well known Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria in Bay Shore, Long Island, New York. We serve signature pasta dishes, salads, entrees and Pizza, Heros, Pizettes, Wraps. We also offer Lunch and Dinner Menus for take-out, delivery and on-site and off-site professional catering service.
Serving Lunch & Dinner Take-Out, Delivery and Dine-In as well as On-site & Off-site Catering.
Pizza
Pizettes
Wraps
Paninis
Heros
Salads
Soups
Appetizers
Pasta Dishes
Baked Dishes
Desserts
Beverages
Italian Specials
Catering
Seafood
Based on 58 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$
Address:
2042 Sunrise Hwy, N Service Rd, Bay Shore, NY 11706
Phone: (631) 619-6900
Website:
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Alexis Flores
my first time here yesterday and it was amazing ! The service was great and the food was even better. I got a Brooklyn slice and a white slice which I’m very particular on but I can’t stress enough how good it was. Everyone was extremely friendly and our food was served right to us at our table. I will definitely be coming back to this establishment!!
… more
Mary O’Neill
1st time going in 5/6/21 the owners personalities are fantastic and contagious. We got our food to go. It was delicious, so good We went for early Mothers Day gathering (6 people), 5/8/21. We ate there. Everything was so absolutely wonderful. Even the chef came out to see if everything was good. It was GREAT! I, 100%, recommend The Classic New York Pizza Joint, for everyone.
… more
Elaina LoGiudice
Just a picky Brooklyn girl looking for a decent slice..
… more
Belle B
I go there all the time food is very good. But the last 3 times I have been there they have messed up the order. Brought pizza to Florida for my parents was supposed to be sausage and pepperoni slices I got sausage and peppers. Didn’t realize it until we got to Florida. The next time same thing I called to order slices ordered 4 slices 2 of those slice again sausage and pepperoni got sausage and peppers and they complained that I called in slices I was still on the phone as they complained took that back but it was after I drove all the way home. Tonight ordered a pie half cheese the other half with sausage and pepperoni all over it I got one side sausage and the other side pepperoni. And the guy repeated it to me and still got it wrong. One time I would like to get the correct order.
… more
Emily M
Tried it tonight because of all the great reviews. Wonderful owners, wonderful customers, and fantastic pizza. We will definitely be back. The spinach and artichoke slice was one of the best slices I’ve ever had.
… more
Jessica Medrano
Alright, normally I don’t take the time to write reviews. But this place left an impression on me. From the food to the customer service. I got a Buffalo chicken slice and a Margherita slice they were excellent. So much chicken on the Buffalo chicken slice I loved it! And the people at the counter were so kind I had an overall great experience:) might make this the spot I go to for pizza:)
… more
Lisa D
This is our new favorite place! With so many pizza places in the area this one by far is the most consistent. The entire staff is helpful and friendly. The food is always hot and fresh! You have to try the Stefano Special….. it is so good (and my favorite)!
… more
Bob omalley
The food here is authentic Italian food the flavors remind me of my “wonder” years in Brooklyn NY.
… more
Daniel Vazquez
This pizza shop has been closed for a long time. I noticed activity about a week ago. Just stopped for a couple of slices. Greeted nicely and the slices were very good. Thanks for bringing pizza back to the shopping center. Delivery is available… very nice. I hear there’s a grand opening. I’ll tell my neighbors!
… more
Glenn Greeley
Best Pizza On Long Island!
… more
… View more
