Classy family-run eatery serving a range of American fare with craft beers, wine & specialty drinks. Based on 738 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
5 S Market St, Troy, OH 45373
Phone: (937) 552-7676
Website: http://thecarolineonthesquare.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 4–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 4–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Joy Finchum
Was excited to try something new and close to home. We were seated at the window facing downtown. The window sill was dirty and had a dead june bug among other debris. Ordered the fried onions for an appetizer and they were cold. He had the Santa Fe Chicken and the chicken itself was flavorless and rice undercooked. I had the glazed salmon. Was asked if I liked a medium center, but was medium rare at best. And you can tell there were no other seasonings besides the glaze dumped over after the salmon was “cooked”. This was a date night for us and we treated ourselves to a $100.00 meal when Cheddars would have been a better option. Very disappointed. Service was good though. She was bright and cheery. I typically don’t complain, but this was subpar food at best.should have read the reviews and based on those, the owner only responds to the positive not addressing the negative. I would’ve expected much more for the money.
… more
Brian Rupright
Service was terrible honestly. But the food definitely made up for it. Crab cakes were delicious along with the bourbon mushrooms.. house steak was perfect!!! Definitely going back when we visit from Michigan.
… more
Deven Wallace (TheCrimsonDJ)
All around amazing experience. The staff were consistently polite and made sure that we had everything we needed. The atmosphere was delightful, with music playing softly in the background. The food was utterly delicious. Highly recommend eating at this establishment and we will most certainly be returning in the future.
… more
Paula Jewett
My choice for my Birthday! Party of 8, including a 2 yr. old. Our food was very good, 6 of us had delicious burgers, cooked to specs YUM! One of our party ordered the Halibut, and reported that it was good, but bland.
… more
Sandy Taylor
IVe been going to this place for years maybe once a week, maybe sometimes, twice. It use to be fun and relaxing but the vibe has changed. The bar is brighter than the dining area and after working underneath overhead lights it’s in an office setting it’s not relaxing. While I was there tonight one man came to talk to the manager because the music was to loud in the dining room and I asked if the lights could be turned down a bit in the bar. They complied but it was obvious the input wasn’t appreciated. There was also an incident tonight where an employee was obviously upset and the person in charge had a conversation in front of customers and it didn’t appear to be friendly. To many things in one evening. I don’t know what changed but will definitely find somewhere else for a relaxing evening.
… more
James Milks
My experience was exquisite. Thank you employees Alie and Ashtin for recommending this.
… more
BillsFlippn Finds
Appetizer wasn’t very good(crabcakes) for the price. Entree was delicious. Service was terrible, our waitress made us feel like we didn’t belong there and heard her talking about another customer because the customer asked her how much a soft drink was. She is Definitely in the wrong profession. Will not go back.
… more
Jason Hess
Last night my wife and I and another couple had dinner here. My wife and I go often but it was our friends first time. We had a reservation which we got seated right away. The Manager told us she was short staffed on wait staff. Long story short. She ended up waiting on multiple tables to make up for the short staff and she was excellent and provided a great experience for our friends for their first time. Kudos!
… more
Ryan Cleary
As one of the PREMIER restaurants of the Dayton region, The Caroline made a very quick appearance on my Dayton Region restaurant list.
… more
Steve Shah
The atmosphere is better than the food. Steak was over cooked. Salad was served warm.
… more
… View more