Based on 81 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 5.0 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
3 Fair St, Carmel Hamlet, NY 10512
Phone: (631) 237-7646
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Charlotte Berwind
That Greek Place on Fair St, near 52 in Carmel. GO!!!! Delicious food. Some of the best I’ve had in our area in a long time. Clean, bright, friendly and the generously portioned, homemade food. My friend and I were eating as if we had been shipwrecked, sampling soups, appetizers, 2 entrees, 3 desserts and a Greek Coffee Frappe that’s will put Starbucks out of business once word gets out.
… more
Lourdes M.
I would give this place 100 stars. The vibe alone captures you. Everyone is so friendly. I felt like a family member as soon as I walk in. The Greek music in the background is definitely appreciated. The food… amazing. I soo recommend this place. I had the chicken yeero plattee today. Delicious! Nóstimo! Sorry, I forgot to take a picture of the yeero.
… more
Katie A
My new favorite restaurant in Carmel! Makes delicious yeeros, desserts, spanakopita, and greek fries with feta on top was amazing! Highly recommend to anyone and everyone. Customer service is the best in town Don’t leave without getting a creme puff! I treated my coworkers at Raymond Opticians for lunch and they LOVED it!
… more
Jacqueline Unger-Sprague
I HIGHLY recommend this place! The minute we walked in the door we were greeted and there was this wonderful, positive energy. The family that owns this place is incredibly kind, genuine, thoughtful and accomodating. They all were so happy and glad to help us. I wish every place was like this one. We all need kindness, especially these days. I was blown away by the service.
… more
Raynor Blom
At the time of writing this review this place has a perfect 5 star rating with 56 reviews, happy to be number 57!
… more
tiffany guziczek
First time ordering from That Greek Place and OMG!! The food is fantastic! We placed a big order for 4 adults and two kids and everyone raved about it. My chicken souvlaki sandwich and fries was so delicious! I cannot wait to order again! So glad you are in the neighborhood!!
… more
nys464
Updating this review after eating here many more times. The food is consistently fresh and delicious. Portions are plenty. The people are very nice. Mama is on staff and making her homemade recipes. Very authentic. I only wish it was open later for those late evening cravings this restaurant gives me. Whether you’re Greek, Cypriot, Turkish, Middle Eastern, or just appreciate those foods, this place will check any of those boxes for you.
… more
George
Excellent meal. Meat in both the yeero and platter was delicious and pita bread was fresh. Will return!
… more
Parker Treadway
Absolutely amazing! Staff was very friendly. Food was phenomenal. My wife got the chicken yeero and I got the lamb with the intention of sharing each others food but let’s be real that did not happen. The food was so good we did not want to share with each other. The baklava is out of this world!
… more
Sofia Swikata Dupi
I love this restaurant! Food is always delicious, never greasy, and the family who runs it is so friendly. it’s my favorite take out in town. Our family faves are: strifti spanikopita, spicy feta dip (seriously, get it), chicken avgolemono soup, gyros, falafel and bougatsa (as good as I’ve ever had outside of Greece) and the ekmek.
… more
… View more