Casual pizzeria using family recipes for its traditional oven-baked pizzas. Based on 70 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
520 W Aurora Rd, Northfield, OH 44067
Phone: (330) 468-8900
Website: http://www.teresaspizza.com/sagamore
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Sunday | 12:30–7:30 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Hannah Bayan
Ordered a large pep pizza Saturday night. Their delivery driver pulled up blasting music in my neighborhood at 9pm. Pizza had long blonde hair in it, matched the delivery drivers hair. Undercooked, doughy in the middle. Horrible.
… more
Sean D
First time trying Teresa’s, won’t be the last. Picked up a Large with sausage and pepperoni. I must admit, when I opened the box I was underwhelmed – the toppings were under the cheese and the pizza didn’t look very “large.” But it was delicious, and they definitely didn’t skimp on anything – plenty of toppings and sauce, and cheese that most places would charge extra for. Good texture and flavor to the crust. I almost took off one star because the price seemed high, but the price is actually in line with what other one-off shops and local chains charge. You can pay much less if you get a promo from a national chain, but but that level of quality just isn’t the same. I can’t justify spending this much all the time but Teresa’s will be a nice treat now and then when I want “good” pizza and not just something quick and cheap. Absolutely worth a try.
… more
LUCY LOU
They always serve exceptional food and service. They have been there a long time an surely beat out Antonio’s who rip you off on delivery an their staff are rude and disgusting.
… more
Lisa Smart
Love their large pepperoni pizza, eat it fresh and hot or as leftovers either way it doesn’t disappoint!
… more
Jon Tucker
Pretty terrible pizza. Their sauce is weirdly thin and soupy and tastes like low-quality prepackaged sauce (think Lunchables). The pizza was light on toppings, drenched in grease, and the crust had a chewy, unpleasant texture. It is the quality I might expect from a *very* cheap frozen supermarket pizza.
… more
tuttwith2ts
Can’t believe some of these negative reviews? I’ve actually never been inside the establishment, I get delivery. Best pizza in town! Only pizza place on Earth that I don’t have to waste a topping on Extra Cheese because they provide so much. Great job, Teresa’s!!!
… more
Kim Tewanger
Our office orders from this location typically once a week. We love the pizza and the salad. Our order has never been wrong.
… more
Amish One
Good pizza at a decent price.
… more
Kimberly Martin
Ordered a large pizza, when they delivered it our order was messed up. Instead of apologizing the girl who answered the phone, “STEPHANIE” thought it was appropriate to just argue and be completely rude to my mother . Not once did she apologize for the mishap. The pizza arrived a complete mess. Literally flavorless mess, and the worst part was the pizza was 90% sauce. Crust and tomato soup pretty much. Besides the fact the pizza was terribly disgusting and I can guarantee that I will never order again, I’ll be sure to let everyone know about this horrible experience. On a good note the delivery guy was really nice.
… more
Gary Tomotchko
Im glad I decided to try this place….I gotta a large pep.and sausage..and it was perfect…taste like the pizza we used to get…taste like a classic pizza…thank you Teresa’s
… more
… View more