Based on 141 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.7 stars. Price $$
Address:
25240 75th St, Salem, WI 53168
Website: http://www.tenutaspizza.com/
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Lara Simmons
We order from here frequently and the food is always excellent. Recently I ordered a pizza and, Instead of light cheese, got extra cheese. I sent them a message on Facebook included a photo of the pizza. They promptly responded, apologized, and offered to remake my pizza for me for free. When I called to order the remake Tony was apologetic, professional and handled it promptly . I got my replacement pizza and it was perfect. Highly recommended for their food and their service.
… more
Russell Coulter
Ordering our pizza was super quick and easy, they staff makes you feel like family when you pick up your order. Everyone had a warm, wonderful attitude, and the pizza was cooked perfect! Best spot around for pizza and other Italian food!
… more
Robert Horrom
We ordered 2 pizzas. Stuffed and thin crust. Both were excellent!! People at counter were extremely friendly. The inside, behind the counter looked awesome. We are coming back. You won’t be disappointed. Nothing like previous owners!!
… more
Adam Haulotte
Worst service ever! This was the fourth time they messed up my order. The pizza was also horrible and I told them I had a coupon and they did not add it. Had to pay the full price for a really bad pizza. I would say to anyone reading this that there are far better places that serve pizza, and it would be better just to get a frozen pizza instead. In other words go somewhere else. On top of that the delivery driver didn’t have a pen and decided it was a good idea to step into my house uninvited while I tried to find a pen. The employees were not nice about how they messed up my order for the fourth time, and told me it was my fault for not mentioning the coupon. Which I did mention it but the staff does not know how to follow simple instructions. The staff needs training on customer service, as well as how to make the food more consistent. DO NOT ORDER FROM HERE THEY ARE UNPLEASANT AND HAVE THE WORST FOOD EVER.
… more
Lisa Biederman
The first time my husband and I ordered from here was like 7 years ago shortly after we moved into our house in Bristol. Everything was aweful and cold we never gave it another chance. I regret that. I called in an order for pick up. I could tell the girl taking my order was training. She was very nice and very thorough. Slower, but she was training and it was very understandable. When I picked my order up, I was greeted by the whom I assume was her boss and the girl training. They were both extremely kind. I thought she did a great job. He was joking around and extremely friendly as well. I apreciated that. I got home and I have to say our food was amazing. Me and my son split a philly steak and it was so good he asked to have the same thing for dinner the following day. i am glad i took a chance. We will DEFINATLY BE ORDERING FROM THEM AGAIN. Thanks for the friendly service
… more
Wren Ewing
The person in the back preparing food wasn’t wearing a mask when we came to pick up our online order (that system is a mess, btw). The menu says the fried mushrooms are homemade, they’re not; they’re the usual frozen ones. The combo app was a mix of various apps piled together, not equivalent to the menu description. The pizza was reportedly good (not great) but only fresh (after just one night, it was trash).
… more
Anthony Martorina
Not the best pizza in town but definitely the only pizza place in town. We had stayed away from this location because of a bad experience we had 10 years ago. Then it went under new management and they offered $5 pizzas with a coupon in the weekly local paper. For $5 we decided to give it a try again. The pizza wasn’t great but it was $5. It was perfect when we needed a quick snack. They ran that promotion for 2 years and obviously it worked because they just recently raised it to $7. Now for $7 it is not worth it because the quality of the toppings was not that good. So we had a nice run but for that price I would be better off getting a frozen pizza at the grocery store next door.
… more
Robert Welch
We ordered from Tenuta’s for our Christmas Eve party and were extremely happy with the food, service and price. The food was plentiful and delicious. We will definitely be repeat customers.
… more
Deborah Phillips
We Just devoured the Family Special Spaghetti with meat balls, garlic bread and 4 generous salads! Under $19.00 and delicious. There was so much in the half sheet pan, that I have spaghetti extras for lunch and another dinner. Under new ownership and I am very pleased. I had only ordered pizza before, but now? the sky’s the limit. VERY good VALUE and tastes great!!
… more
Allen McKillips
Went to order pizza. Had a coupon for a medium pizza. So we order 2 pizzas with that coupon and then went to order my free appetizer and they refused me to use my free appetizer. They said I had to buy a pizza at regular price. No where on the free appetizer did it say I had to buy a pizza at a regular price. It was a scratch off thing that we won a free appetizer with. When I explain that to them they still refused to take my free appetizer coupon. The I explain to her to cancel our order and we will go else where. Wont go back. Pretty sad the wont honor their coupons. Bad business!!
… more
… View more