Pizza & casual Italian eats served in a rehabbed tire garage with outdoor seating & a bocce court. Based on 800 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
254 W Washington St, Athens, GA 30601
Phone: (706) 543-1523
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9 PM
Holiday hours
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Issac Morgan
We came to Athens for a little day trip. TMB was highly recommended by multiple locals and Google. Had the chicken parm sub. Did not like it. It was very bland and dry. The breaded chicken really wasn’t breaded, and it didn’t have enough sauce. I had to add salt, crushed red pepper, and ranch (which costs $1 for a little container, why?) to make it taste like something. I only ate half before i gave up on it. The kids had pizza and spaghetti. They also didn’t eat but about half. The desserts: Banana pudding was good. The cake pop was not. Caramel cheesecake was good. The service was amazing, and that goes a long way. The atmosphere was cool. I won’t be coming back. Overall, nothing to rave about or to recommend to anyone.
… more
Dez Partlow
The food to me was a small portion. The service was good. Parking was tight, and limited.
… more
Kiah Newton
What a surprise! I walked up because of the smells and the atmosphere, I was disappointed that it was thin crust (as I have never loved thin crust) but was happily surprised with the flavors. Honestly, a fuller crust may have taken away from this. I was a little apprehensive of the prices as well, however, it ended up doing the trick for my husband and I. All around, I was impressed and probably will go back again.
… more
Lisa E. (Cardigan Queen)
Cool, funky setting. The flavors here are complex, not really a kid’s pizza joint. The marinara had a smoky, almost curried flavor – very interesting. The salad and house dressing are fresh but a lot of the breads were dry. I enjoyed the antipasto with lots of fancy meats and olives. They had some great looking desserts in the case and I tried the banana pudding cupcake. While I think everything is a pretty solid three here, those cupcakes were a FIVE!
… more
Shipra Gupta
Excellent service. Very courteous staff. I ordered pesto pasta, goat cheese crostini and watermelon gazpacho. The soup and the appetizer were good. Though there was no taste of watermelon in the soup. The
… more
Shay Adair
I LOVE this place. Whatever their employees are paid, they absolutely all deserve a raise. Excellent food, beyond excellent customer service. My favorite local pizza place in town!
… more
Maximum RobespierreXVII (Max)
I liked this place. It had a good vibe and the food was pretty good but I really had one issue with the pizza. The style of pizza they do is more like wood fired and they just put too much cheese on which makes it a little hard to eat. It tastes good but is a bit overwhelming.
… more
Farhad Hossain Masum
So far, the best pizza in Athens. I really don’t understand anything else other than thin crusted pizza. And Ted has a good approach to that. Service is minimal. After we sat down, nobody came to our table. You have to walk to the counter, grab a menu, and order there. They do bring the food to your table, and service is REALLY FAST when there is less crowd. I will definitely come here again to try the other pizzas.
… more
Simona Arroyo
Walked here for lunch with a few coworkers. First time visit. Staff were friendly, prompt, and helpful. I had a baby calzone with the house salad upgrade. Food was came quickly and was very delicious. This is definitely a new favorite lunch spot.
… more
A- Lane
I found another gem in this college town thanks to my dear friend Maria. The calzones are well worth the bucks, and the customer service is okay. I’d say they could improve their customer service skills a bit, in that, our drinks never once got refilled and when we arrived there, we saw workers eating in the baking area. I personally think that workers should not eat in the place where they bake and that our drinks should get filled. It’s not like they were busy. Other than that, I would go back.
… more
… View more