Longtime, unfussy pizzeria with counter-service, offering Italian food, sandwiches & lots of beer. Based on 320 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Drive-through ✔️ Delivery
Address:
5101 Mayfield Rd, Lyndhurst, OH 44124
Phone: (440) 449-1252
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Fwant
Possibly the most unique pizza I have ever had. I’m a truck driver that delivers next door once a week and finally got around to trying this place. the smells that come from this place remind me of my all time favorite pizza spot. first off, the people were incredibly nice. felt like a family atmosphere and I was greeted with a smile. the pizza is incredibly unique. not sure I’ve ever had anything quite like it. it’s greasy but not too heavy. I don’t want to make a fool of myself guessing what their cheese blend is but man, it’s the star of the show. the sauce was fresh and I love love love the move of putting the pepperoni under the cheese. at the end of the day this pizza was an A+. thanks for the excellent pie!
… more
Ian Sheehan
Great place! Need to come around more often, Joey a young stud athlete who chefs great pizzas needs a raise. Some thugs were messing with my car and he ran them off. Great guy, really recommend this place. Best place in Ohio!!
… more
Mark Matthews
Must have been an off night. We normally love the food here, but this time was disappointing. We ordered carry out, I ordered grilled chicken salad which is described with iceberg and romaine, but there was no romaine. The lettuce itself was old and brown, not very fresh. Ordered extra dressing for her salad, didn’t get it. I ordered 2 meat balls, but received only one. It was yummy though. We’ll still eat here, hopefully a better experience next time.
… more
Chris Hubert
This is our favorite take out pizza place. The homemade meatballs are an awesome topping choice. Order a size larger than you think you normally need. Both because it’s good and also because the pizzas run a bit smaller than expected.
… more
John L
I would like to give this quaint family establishment a better review, everyone was very friendly and polite. Unfortunately the things I enjoyed about my experience end there. Ordered a large pizza and cheesy garlic bread to eat-in. Pizza was quite expensive considering the sparse toppings it had, definitely needed more cheese. The homemade crust and sauce were quite good though. The cheesy garlic bread wasn’t quite cooked enough, again barely any cheese and what was there wasn’t quite cooked. Seemed like a great place for large groups.
… more
MaryBeth Catullo
My sons and I had a great time. We ordered ahead and our pizza was ready when we got there. We picked out drinks from an enormous selection (alcoholic beverages galore, but we settled for iced tea on a Monday afternoon.) we had a large half pepperoni half plain and the guys & I smashed! There was one man working the whole place and two other tables with customers- props to him for keeping it together. Wish he would have help- they are hiring! They have sports pictures & memorabilia all over the walls, tv’s, and a self serve station which is awesome. Bathroom was very clean and food delicious. Can’t beat the price!
… more
Susan Wagaman
Excellent Pizza…such fresh homemade ingredients. Very pleasurable staff and very reasonable prices. Great menu to choose from. Our first visit and we will become regulars.
… more
Arthur J Horton
The food was great the service was excellent the Atmosphere is cozy and quiet I love it
… more
Dillan Laszlo
Best pizza I’ve ever had in the country hands down little greasy but ur gonna get that with real cheese and quality ingredients I drive 8 hours almost strictly for this pizza
… more
Prudence Bronsky
I had been here years ago and my my spaghetti was not good at all. So I never went back. But today my daughter wanted spaghetti so they have a buy one get one so we tried it. I have to say I’m glad I did. The spaghetti was great. The portions are large and it had lots of sauce. And they have great meatballs. I’m am definitely glad I went to try it again. We will definitely be back for more
… more
… View more