We are Syracuse first Authentic Chicago Deep Dish/and New York Style Pizzeria. Full pizza slice counter with all your favorites and many new. Chargrilled wings, Hot and cold Grinders, Salads, desserts and so much. We are locally owned and operated. Come check us out, we are your one stop shop for all your pizza needs. Tangy Tomato, where we make them deeeeep!!!!
Based on 169 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1428 Burnet Ave, Syracuse, NY 13206
Phone: (315) 314-6090
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 12–10 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
The Reviewer
The woman working the front counter was very patient with me trying to figure what I wanted to get. I landed on the combo deal 2 cheese ny style cheese pizza slices and a pop for $6.99. She warmed them up and off we went. They tasted good – the green little spice was nice – oregano maybe? I wish the cheese was a bit more salty or the sauce has more taste to it. But overall was satisfied.
… more
Dominic Salemi
I was hoping for better.. service was great. Pizza came with cheese all on one side; driver must’ve fast and furious-ed it over to me.. disappointed unfortunately. Looks horrible; had to re-cheese everything.. good news is it tastes great. Wings nice and crispy; pizza has great flavor and taste. Eat in and shouldn’t have any problems!!
… more
gabrielle king
50cent wing Tuesday’s. $27 total for 50 wings! We got salt n pepper, hot, bbq and Sammy sauce! Perfect as always!
… more
Autumn Gilbert
Wanted some wings and decided to try here on a Friday evening. Ordered online via Slice and it was simple, set a pick up time for an hour out. When I arrived I could tell they were busy, even still I was greeted promptly, kindly and my order was finished on time. Making customers feel welcomed is really a big deal for me so I knew I’d return off that. I enjoyed the wings, they were crispy like I asked, but I wanted more flavor/sauce (I ordered hot wings). Like I said, I’ll be going back to try more of what they have to offer.
… more
Nikki Deshensky
Was in town for a conference and heard this place made awesome Chicago style deep dish pizza. We tried 2 of the 12″, one Buffalo chicken and one veggie. Both were made to order + were completely awesome, and with leftovers to take back. Garlic knots were huge, crispy and delicious. It’s not a fancy place by any stretch but it was clean and the staff were friendly and professional. It’s definitely worth stopping in.
… more
Jeffrey DiCocco
Good sauce, crispy bottom, and amazing crust. Wings were good and crispy. Place was clean and service was friendly. This was my first time here and will certainly not be the last. It’s hard to rise to the top in a city like Syracuse where good pizza is all over the place but these folks have done it. Do yourself a favor and eat here.
… more
Marisa
Really liked our food from Tangy Tomato. Split a 10inch deep dish veggie pizza (with plenty leftover) and an order of wings, sweet chili, paid an extra dollar for grilled wings, so worth it! Everything was delicious and done right. I love how the cheese melts into the pizza dough like you’re biting into one big cheesy bite. That, and the fresh tomato sauce on top is what will bring me back.
… more
Hasan
Was on the hunt for some authentic New York style pizza and finally found the place. They sell pizza by the slice and have several toppings to choose from. I ordered the cheese and the garlic. They were both flavorful and delicious. The crust had a nice crunch to it. The cheese and sauce were balanced and not overpowering. The staff is very friendly and helpful. I also ordered some garlic knots, which were really good and addicting. They have lunch specials from 11 am – 4 pm. Great spot to check out if you’re looking for a fresh New York style pizza.
… more
Jackie Robinson
My pie came to $41.25, very good taste it was suppose to be a garlic deep dish pie with an inch of crust that should have been filled with toppings, we also ordered a $17.00 cheese steak Smaller than jreck subs, again good flavor Bread Delicious! Fries taste Home Made’: Great Taste But the serving size is Not Worth the Money!!
… more
Rob Oatman
The folks here are doing pretty well, considering the place has been open for just two months. The first thing you notice is how many pickups and slice orders are being processed. It was busy! That says something right there.
… more
… View more