Homemade dough defines NY-style pies at this casual spot with a range of Italian comfort dishes. Based on 304 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
967 Sebastian Blvd, Sebastian, FL 32958
Phone: (772) 581-4441
Website: http://www.facebook.com/pages/TJs-NY-Style-Pizza-Sebastian-FL/147530015262751?ref=hl
Hours
| Saturday | 3–9 PM |
| Sunday | 3–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 3–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 3–9 PM |
| Thursday | 3–9 PM |
| Friday | 3–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Aazgaroth
Pizza was OK, nothing great. Pizza was a bit overcooked so the crust edge was inedible. Giorgios in Vero Beach or Palermos in Melbourne is significantly better. This location is cash only, but they nicely let you know BEFORE you order, so nbd. Staff is super friendly and professional. Can recommend this business for customer service but not for the food. It’s adequate at best.
… more
Marge
Hands down the ( BEST PIZZA) In and around Sebastian .don’t throw your money away on other Pizza places !!!! You won’t be happy . Trust me I Love Pizza and have tried them all. I always get my family’s Pizza at TJs Delish and Fresh perfectly Done. thank you for great Pizza Sandy
… more
Diana Hannot
Cash only is legal, but practical? Great Pizzas and antipasti salad. Really a take out restaurant with some seating.
… more
Chloe Kelley
There pizza was burnt, and 19.45 for one pizza. Nothing else included. It’s mostly bland.
… more
Brian Young
Almost $60 for 2 16” pizza. The staff is rude. Pizza is actually pretty good but service is terrible and way overpriced. Won’t be coming back. Also it’s cash only.
… more
Mightymommy 101214
Sebastian is a small town so Pizza selection is limited. With that said, this place holds its own with pizza. If you’re a fan of the thinner, crunchier crust this place is for you. Not overly impressed with their wings. They were REALLY little And many of them broken. I’m pretty sure they counted each half of the broken ones as ONE. Hot wings definitely aren’t HOT. Last but not least- this is a CASH ONLY establishment. Honestly, this is a real issue in this day and age. Who carries cash? Anyone can download Venmo and accept payments. If all you carry is a card then this place isn’t an option for you.
… more
Anni Smith
Love this place!! I am usually a thin and crispy crust girl, but TJ’s NY style is top notch. Don’t even get me started on the cheesecake. So delicious. Best pizza in Sebastian, great folks behind the counter, what’s not to love?
… more
Luxury Lady
Where do I begin? We had actually stopped ordering from. TJ’s because of the inconsistency in quality. Sometimes you will get an amazing pizza, other times its burnt. Also the wings are never fresh as advertised. And if you call and let them know you get the 3rd degree on how every thing is homemade from scratch and fresh. In other words the customer is never right. So anyways after taking a pretty long break from ordering , we decide to give them another shot. Wrong decision. Our food was delivered an hour and fifteen minutes later not the 45 minutes promised. Our food was cold and my pizza roll was incorrect. So I call to let them know and am pretty much told I am wrong. Next the gaslighting begins. The woman whom answered the phone a accused me of being loud and threatening. The truth is I could not get a word in edgewise. I was told that my order was indeed correct despite my looking at the incorrect order.
… more
Russell P
I called, they don’t take cards, I forgot I called when they first opened and had forgotten why I never tried their pizza. My wife and I order delivery often as our lives are busy.
… more
joy jaskula
We just ordered a 16” pizza and asked for it well done since I like it a bit crunchy. It was SO great! Best pizza I’ve had in a long time. I just moved to the area and I won’t be getting my pizza anywhere else. 2 of us could only manage to eat half. My husband couldn’t use a credit card, had to pay w cash. Amber who answered the phone was very upbeat and def loves her job.
… more
… View more