Laid-back tavern, known for its burgers & wings, with a full bar & TVs for sports watching. Based on 646 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
214 NY-59, Suffern, NY 10901
Phone: (845) 357-6556
Website: http://suttersmillsuffern.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Investigator K. Lynch
Do not pass up this local gem. Burgers are amazing, juicy, flavorful, and are chock full of quality ingredients, the perfect mixture of beef, cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, perched on-top of a bun that is buttery and toasted to perfection. The fries are no longer the nostalgic steak fries Sutters is known for, rather, your fries are a rustic cut potato, lightly salted to perfection. The chicken tenders were breaded and fried, not greasy, and they were massive. The pieces of chicken you are getting when you order the tenders aren’t your average tenders, you get your moneys worth here people. Wings are massive, crispy, and slathered in teriyaki, buffalo, mango habaneros, or traditional buffalo sauce. The pulled pork nachos combine savory and tangy pulled pork with a wonderful white cheese sauce, piled high on top of house made tortilla chips. This place is HIGHLY recommended.
… more
Debby “Brew” Sherr
‘First time visiting Sutter’s Mill, it’s a great little find! The atmosphere is casual and fun, decorated for Halloween.
… more
John Arehart
Never noticed this place before, probably because it’s on the end of a little strip mall at a busy intersection. It came up on my GPS so I tried it. Service was friendly and food was delicious. I had the French Onion Soup and a cheeseburger with cheese fries. I was completely stuffed but it was all soooo good. I had to laugh because the tagline on the menu says, “Great Food at Old Fashioned Prices” and my lunch with tip was $35! Oh well, it was delicious …. I’ll share some pictures. The place was empty when I got there but then filled up before I left.
… more
The Dragon Born Your Brother
Bartender overcharged me and my friends by $30. Called my Credit card and there is no refund processing… So not only did she over charge me $30 she charged me another subsequent $21 so now I’m out $51 and WILL be disputing this on my credit card. Funny she said she did the math wrong in her head but I saw her use a calculator as she was looking at the bill. Never coming here again which is a shame because the food was good. Stealing from your customers because you think they are under the influence is a horrible business practice.
… more
Laura S
Bar restaurant. Lots of bar food coices on the simple menu. At the corner of a small strip mall. Served quickly for a late lunch. Our waiter was very cordial and did a good job. Food was good and reasonably priced. I would recommend and return. Will probably try something different next time.
… more
Jessica Murphy
We took a little break from dinner at Sutters but after reading a review about the new kitchen we decided to try it again.
… more
Michelle Gebbia
The food was delicious! Able to sit immediately! The servers were attentive and kind, food was served without a feeling of waiting, and the prices were very reasonable!
… more
Ed
I Ordered Buffalo wings and honestly forgot how good they are here. The cheese burger sliders were cooked just right. Steak Fries with gravy hit the spot and the beers are cold. Good spot I need to come here more often.
… more
songej1
Was always a great place. They had some issues with the cook for a while and the food became sub par but they are back! Everything was great tonight.
… more
Nathalie JB
I dined in for a quick stop on the road. Found this spot on Google maps and decided to give it a chance. I had the cheeseburger with fries and a Guinness beer. It was one of the best medium rare burgers I’ve ever had. So juicy! I usually add mayo to my burgers but this one did not need any. perfection! However, I felt like the beer was served a bit too luke warm so I asked for a cup of ice. Not the best experience I’ve had with a beer. And it was a sad finish to my meal. But overall excellent customer service. Our server was very welcoming and kind. Also I’m willing to volunteer my graphic design skills for a drink menu! ♀️
… more
… View more