Formerly known as Proportion Cafe
Menu Items Include but are not limited to
Salads • Wraps • Paninis • Warm Grain Bowls • Frozen Yogurt • Protein Shakes !
In addition to our menu items
We have (build your own) options
We have a wide variety of options to choose from
– Vegetables, Grains, Proteins, Lettuces, & Homemade Dressings –
We will offer delivery & catering !
Based on 67 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
2460 Nesconset Hwy, Stony Brook, NY 11790
Phone: (631) 751-8050
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 10 AM–7 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–7 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–7 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–7 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–7 PM |
| Sunday | 10 AM–7 PM |
| Monday | 10 AM–7 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Gabby Brauner
Absolutely delicious. Everything felt fresh and was very tasty. I’ve been twice so far. Once, I got a custom salad that was a really nice size and yummy, albeit on the expensive side (but fair). Second time, I got a Mediterranean wrap that I can’t stop thinking about! I’ll definitely be back. Also, everyone working there was very kind!
… more
Stephen Germana
I’ve been here probably about a dozen times but it has gotten progressively more inconsistent.
… more
Beverly Gross
Yesterday my mom suggested going to Supreme Salads in Stony Brook for lunch. I wasn’t to thrilled about the idea since I didn’t feel a salad would fill me up. Even when we pulled up to the location the store looked small and I didn’t think I would like it, boy was I wrong! This place is fabulous!!! The store is very big. It is long and even has seating. The store is very clean and offers a variety of salads to choose from, including a build your own salad, panini’s, even protein drinks. This store has everything you can ask for and more. I chose the build your own salad, priced at $12.49. Don’t let the price scare you, the salad was huge and more than I could eat in one sitting. It filled me up, something that never happens to me when it comes to a salad. The build you salad let’s you choose up to 5 different basic toppings, there’s a small charge if you want more. I never saw such a big list of foods to choose from when ordering a salad. You can even pick your own lettuce; romaine, iceberg, spinach, arcadia mix, kale, or argula. They even have premium and supreme toppings or protein meats , grilled chicken, steak, tofu, and shrimp. I was thrilled. I ordered my salad and the girl chopped up the salad for me at no additional charge and added the dressing. Note- most restaurants charge more to chop your salad and 23 different choices of dressing to choose from. There is something for everyone. The salad was absolutely fresh and delicious. This is the place to go if you want to eat healthy. I just recently started seeing a nutritionist and can’t wait to my next visit just to tell her about this place. I found Heaven on Earth. This establishment also has large canvass type posters all along the wall which displays different foods explaining why that food would be a good food choice to put in your salad by listing the benefits, vitimans, and minerals. I wish I discovered Supreme Salads sooner, I will be a return customer.
… more
Hope Froehlich
This place is very hit or miss. Sometimes my salad is perfect other times I can’t believe I paid that high of a price for what it is. If you’re gonna charge upwards of 22$+ for a salad, It shouldn’t be sometimes good. I love a good salad and unfortunately there’s not many of these types of places on the island, and i am willing to pay the price for it, but they need to be more consistent in quality. It’s not worth it when your lettuce and veggies are soggy and mushy (I didnt have them put dressing on it either). I was disappointed in my salad and wasted $22 today which is why I’m leaving a review. 🙁
… more
Fatima Daoud
These portions are *gigantic* in a good way (I understand the name now!)
… more
Asli Pisano
First time trying this place. Really friendly service and big portions! This was a side salad (you can add veggies, choice of meat, cheese, and dry toppings). Definitely more than enough for 2 people.
… more
Asia Toscano
I’ve been here before to order and pick up for my elderly mother. She loves it and its her special treat. Tonight was strange. I was the only customer and was left there waiting to order for quite sometime. A young lady was diligently working behind the counter so no worries. Finally, a young gentleman offered to serve me after meandering around. I didn’t even realize he was someone who worked behind the counter. He made my mom’s Southwestern, salad, however, I questioned whether the tortilla strips were in it as it didn’t look so. He stated they were. No, Josh, they were not. If I return in the future, I’ll watch the entire process to ensure the salad is up to expectations. Disappointed.
… more
Dan
Don’t be afraid of the prices – you’re getting a large portion of high quality food. Delicious food and clean, small establishment. I never write reviews but I’ll definitely be coming back here.
… more
D R
Heard a friend say how they liked the food so I gave it a try. Staff super pleasant and helpful, place is spotless and could eat off the floor and everything looks super fresh. I ordered the Southwest salad with grilled chicken with the recommended chipotle ranch dressing to go. Large portion size and tasted fantastic. You won’t be disappointed.
… more
Lenox Edwards Jr
I give this place 10/10 so you gotta get here to try it out! And when you come ask Alex or Courtney to help you and I guarantee they won’t disappoint. I had a spicy Caesar wrap on the habanero cheddar wrap and I could eat it 3x a day. This is the #1 spot for the post-workout meal. Trust me you’ll thank me later.
… more
… View more