Sugar Creek Barbeque Co Menu – Nashville, IN

Type : Barbecue restaurant

Location : Nashville, IN

Based on 382 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery

Sugar Creek Barbeque Co 47448

Address:
51 Chestnut St, Nashville, IN 47448

Phone: (812) 988-5810

Website:

Hours

Sunday 11 AM–3 PM
Monday

(Labor Day)
Closed
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday Closed
Thursday Closed
Friday 11 AM–2 PM, 4–8 PM
Saturday 11 AM–2 PM, 4–8 PM

Menu

All Day
The “1932”
Favorite. Our pit master’s favorite. Our pit master pays homage to our patriarch with his take on our classic pulled pork sandwich with 10 oz of pork drizzled in our sweet creek sauce and topped with our smokehouse mac and cheese.
$12.99
1/3 Lb Sandwich
With house chips.
$6.99
1/3 Lb Sandwich
With side of choice.
$8.49
BBQ Plate
With two sides and bread.
$10.99
2 Meat Combo
4 oz each.
$14.59
3 Meat Combo
3 oz each meat.
$15.59
Barbeque Beans $2.79
House Cut Fries $2.79
Potato Salad $2.79
Mac N Cheese $2.79
Onion Rings $2.79
Green Beans $2.79
Side Salad $2.59
House Coleslaw $2.79
Side Sampler Plate
Select any three sides served with cornbread.
$7.99
Chicken Tender Dinner
Served with fries and dipping sauce.
$8.99
Classic Creek Cheese Burger
Favorite. House seasoned 12 lb burger, cooked to order with fresh never frozen premium beef. With two slices of American cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, sliced red onion, pickle and our signature sauce. Served with side of fries.
$9.99
Indiana Tenderloin
Our thick cut 8 oz tenderloin, breaded and fried golden brown. Topped with lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle. Served with side of your choice.
$9.99
Wick’s Sugar Cream Pie
Favorite. Indiana state pie!!!
$2.99
Soft Drinks $2.29
Iced Teas & Lemonades $2.29
Local Sidetrack Coffee Roasters
Local roasted house blend coffee.
$1.99
Fried Biscuits
Favorite. 10 golden brown biscuits served with apple butter or strawberry jam.
$5.99
BBQ Nachos
Pulled pork served atop a bed of fresh made tortilla chips, topped with creek sweet sauce, cheese sauce, shredded cheese, sour cream and jalapeños.
$6.99
Dirty Fries
A heaping portion of our new specialty cut house fries, topped with Cheddar and queso cheeses then piled high with our “almost famous” pulled pork and topped with our signature Creek sweet sauce.
$8.99
Friday & Saturday Menu
The “1932”
Favorite. Our pit master’s favorite. Our pit master pays homage to our patriarch with his take on our classic pulled pork sandwich with 10 oz of pork drizzled in our sweet creek sauce and topped with our smokehouse mac and cheese.
$12.99
St. Louis Ribs $14.99
Ribs Platter
Choose our St. Louis cut spare ribs or our baby back ribs, served with two sides.
$17.99
Creek Bar-B-Q Feast
Half slab St. Louis or baby backs and your choice of two more meats and two sides.
$24.99
1/3 Lb Sandwich
With house chips.
$6.99
1/3 Lb Sandwich
With side of choice.
$8.49
BBQ Plate
With two sides and bread.
$10.99
2 Meat Combo
4 oz each.
$14.59
3 Meat Combo
3 oz each meat.
$15.59
Barbeque Beans $2.79
House Cut Fries $2.79
Potato Salad $2.79
Mac N Cheese $2.79
Onion Rings $2.79
Green Beans $2.79
Side Salad $2.79
House Coleslaw $2.79
Side Sampler Plate
Select any three sides served with cornbread.
$6.99
Chicken Tender Dinner
Served with fries and dipping sauce.
$8.99
Classic Creek Cheese Burger
Favorite. House seasoned 12 lb burger, cooked to order with fresh never frozen premium beef. With two slices of American cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, sliced red onion, pickle and our signature sauce. Served with side of fries.
$9.99
Indiana Tenderloin
Our thick cut 8 oz tenderloin, breaded and fried golden brown. Topped with lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle. Served with side of your choice.
$9.99
Wick’s Sugar Cream Pie
Favorite. Indiana state pie!!!
$2.99
Soft Drinks $2.49
Local Sidetrack Coffee Roasters
Local roasted house blend coffee.
$1.99
Fried Biscuits
Favorite. 10 golden brown biscuits served with apple butter or strawberry jam.
$5.99
BBQ Nachos
Pulled pork served atop a bed of fresh made tortilla chips, topped with creek sweet sauce, cheese sauce, shredded cheese, sour cream and jalapeños.
$6.99
Dirty Fries
A heaping portion of our new specialty cut house fries, topped with Cheddar and queso cheeses then piled high with our “almost famous” pulled pork and topped with our signature Creek sweet sauce.
$8.99

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Deborah Burkhart
Found this place from a Yelp search. Outstanding BBQ. Best brisket I’ve ever had. Dirty Fries provided a different experience with every bite: savory salty crunchy smooth. Excellent pulled pork. The homemade sauces provide a wide range of sweet and HOT. Go for the Reaper if like your brow sweating. I do! Service was fast and friendly. Decor spot on with BBQ kitsch: flying pink pigs and signs with cheeky sayings.

… more

Matt Bentley
Went here prior to a Brown County Music Center show. Conveniently located. Only took two minutes to get seat while it was an hour wait everywhere else in town. Staff was super friendly and attentive. Food was delicious; fried biscuits and apple butter were a treat, brisket was moist and tasty, onion rings were some of the best around. Will be coming back next time around Nashville.

… more

Steve Motherwell
Best BBQ we’ve had in awhile. So good, in fact, we had to go back and get an order “to go”. We had the 3-meat which consisted of smoked brisket, shredded pork and sausage. We had baked beans and coleslaw as sides. Sweet tea and sugar pie rounded out our meal. Two thumbs up!!

… more

Kevin Deboy
Tonight on Kevin’s Diner

… more

Cassandra Brown
Very tender brisket and pork! The chips served with the sandwich were great, salty and crispy. The server was hustling the whole room herself and was an expert at it. Big servings and affordable food, especially for Nashville. Shown is The Old Man sandwich and Brisket Platter.

… more

Laura Cortner
The fried biscuits were the best thing on the menu! I would go back for those! The service was quick and the meats were Ok.. had to try the local pie, but wouldn’t again.

… more

Kelly Frank
Small little place away from downtown and all the crowds. Friendly staff and good food. They have a really delicious hand breaded tenderloin that is a nice thickness . If you’re really hungry the be sure to try the dump truck . Waitress was friendly, but she could have checked on us a bit more . We will still go back if we’re in the area . They are reasonable priced for the offering they have , which is not just barbecue .

… more

Cindy Eccles
We picked up and ate at home. It was delicious. The Mac and cheese was so creamy and the slaw was excellent. And of course the pork bbq was the best! Thank you!! Also we bought in bulk so we didn’t have dinners.

… more

Lonnie Perry
Everything about our visit was absolutely delicious! We were warmly welcomed when walked in the door. We were quickly seated. Everyone in our group enjoyed their order. The French Fries are the best in Nashville! The Fried Biscuits with apple butter appetizer were delicious (they were devoured before I could get a picture). Our waitress provided top notch service that matched the top notch food. The facility was clean and had a nice atmosphere.

… more

FR Jackson
We tried the brisket, turkey, tenderloin and sides. We were not disappointed! Everything was really good. The cornbread was like eating a piece of butter cake, so delicious!

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions